Side imaging: is it worth it?

  • docfrigo
    Wisconsin
    Posts: 1564
    #1294981

    A simple answer: yes.
    Some of my friends have asked me how has it been going since running SI-DI v/s regular 2D sonar.
    My basic analogy to them has been it’s like an X-ray v/s a CAT scan-both great tools but can do very different things.
    Your regular 2D can be thought of much like an X-ray machine, shooting a cone of energy down like a shotgun blast.
    Side-imaging or down-imaging shoots thin slices of energy, thus like a CAT scan machine, gives a much more detailed picture of what is going on. Much like a CAT scan, you really do see exactly what is going on down there.
    Will SI-DI replace my 2D? My answer to that is “no”. The regular 2D gives me a great interpretation of bottom hardness, target hardness, thermoclines and water temp. differences, well as currents. My SI-DI gives me great target seperation, an actual picture of what I am looking at, better clarity and whole host of other features. In a sense, the SI and DI is like “further studies” being done, much like getting a CAT scan after seeing something on an X-ray that has to be checked out further. I am sure there are a few on this site that have had an X-ray done on their lowback only to have their doctor say “we need a CAT scan to check this out further”.
    So, I run both at the same time, just like having access to an X-ray and CAT scan at the same time.
    So if you get a chance, jump into a buddies boat that has this new technology and you too can drive around for hours at end just looking at the bottom.

    Thanks Jason for all the great posts, you sure have cut down the learning curve on this great new techology.

    Jeremy

    kris_brantner
    My river
    Posts: 1678
    #848618

    i have to disagree. no its not worth it………….

    whittsend
    Posts: 2389
    #848623

    I would say it’s worth it for me, but everyone has different pricepoints, affordability issues, technical savy, time spent on the water, and gadget enjoyment levels…

    I could spend all day staring at the screen, not fishing, just looking at structure. The “gee-whiz” value alone made it worth it for me. It has helped me catch fish, though, as well. The first time I had it out I found an amazing looking spot on the SI… Turned around, trolled over it and caugt a walleye. That spot (which I never would have found without SI) has proven to be THE BEST location to consistantly boat fish on that lake.

    Salary, frugality, time on the water, etc, make being “worth it” a VERY subjective and individual matter. If you can afford it, spend a decent amount of time on the water each year, would like another fish-catching advantage, and would enjoy the gee-whiz technology (while being able to understand the data and apply it to fishing situations — which isn’t hard, BTW), I’d say it would be worth it for you.

    Mike

    perch_44
    One step ahead of the Warden.
    Posts: 1589
    #848624

    Quote:


    i have to disagree. no its not worth it………….


    explain…

    smackem
    Iowa Marshall Co
    Posts: 956
    #848625

    Quote:


    i have to disagree. no its not worth it………….



    Oh man I hope your mistaken. I just dropped 3 grand on the 1197 Will have a chance to test drive this unit more this month.

    docfrigo
    Wisconsin
    Posts: 1564
    #848636

    I am assuming Kris is referring to price point and his opinion is welcomed. Personally, I bought my 997 used after saving money up for it-no bigger tightwad than me. Well, maybe TomP is bad as me but it is a close race!
    After updating my 997, good as new!

    Jeremy

    targaman
    Inactive
    Wilton, WI
    Posts: 2759
    #848658

    The fish just don’t have a chance these days. Eventually fishing will be so easy it won’t even be fun anymore…

    Jesse Krook
    Y.M.H.
    Posts: 6403
    #848683

    Quote:


    i have to disagree. no its not worth it………….


    Please do explain

    Did you have a bad experience, unit, or just not sponsored by Humminbird ?

    t-ellis
    Colorado Springs, CO
    Posts: 1316
    #848686

    Quote:


    Quote:


    i have to disagree. no its not worth it………….


    Please do explain

    Did you have a bad experience, unit, or just not sponsored by Humminbird ?


    He’s a Bass fisherman!! I doubt any serious Bass fisherman need any new technology to up their game. I’m sure KVD feels the same way after winning the classic.

    theodorenugget
    Sugar Land, TX
    Posts: 609
    #848695

    Quote:


    The fish just don’t have a chance these days. Eventually fishing will be so easy it won’t even be fun anymore…


    even when I find them I can’t seem to make them bite.

    smackem
    Iowa Marshall Co
    Posts: 956
    #848723

    OK $2700 but that’s purdy close

    mojogunter
    Posts: 3303
    #848735

    Quote:


    i have to disagree. no its not worth it………….


    I would like to hear your opinons as well as to it not being worth the money. The technology isn’t cheap, but if you say it doesn’t make you a better fisherman then something is wrong with the unit you have, or you haven’t a clue how it works. I had to go to a class at Thorne Brothers a couple of years ago when I got mine to understand what I was looking at, but after the learning curve it is a great tool.

    silverstreak
    West Union, IA
    Posts: 250
    #848761

    did u have to go to a class to learn what u were looking at when u picked your avatar maybe it was double vision

    Wade Boardman
    Grand Rapids, MN
    Posts: 4453
    #848767

    Quote:


    Side imaging: is it worth it?



    I don’t understand the question.

    whittsend
    Posts: 2389
    #848778

    Quote:


    did u have to go to a class to learn what u were looking at when u picked your avatar maybe it was double vision


    Ugghhh… No offense to the writer, but it takes me about 5 times longer to read the above text vs if “u” was spelled out “you”..

    Not a phone shorthand / texting guy I guess…

    docfrigo
    Wisconsin
    Posts: 1564
    #848779

    “is it worth it?”

    Price v/s the gain in knowledge.

    Brad Juaire
    Maple Grove, MN
    Posts: 6101
    #848790

    My 1197 side imaging is certainly worth it since I use it as a scouting tool looking for suspended walleyes in the open basin of Mille Lacs. Since I’m able to scan up to 300 feet of water at a time, I’m able to eliminate more water and locate more fish in a shorter amount of time.

    justinwitmer
    Posts: 124
    #848812

    I hope all this new technology also brings about increased levels of catch and release!

    fishalot31
    Brooklyn Park
    Posts: 51
    #848859

    Most definitely! Finally got to test my 997csi out today. WOW! The views you see with any standard 2d sonar can now be explained. What’s not to like! Side scan and down imaging are very usefull tools to decipher the structure in any lake or river and give you an almost picture like view of the bottom.

    Tom P.
    Whitehall Wi.
    Posts: 3526
    #849128

    Nice analogy DOC.

    For me my answer is yes it is worth it. I would give up a lot of other things in my boat before I would give up the SI technology.

    As Jason allways says get a big enough screen to where it hurts a little bit. With SI screen size is a BIG DEAL.

    whittsend
    Posts: 2389
    #849133

    Quote:


    I hope all this new technology also brings about increased levels of catch and release!


    It definately can put you over the fish, which is waaay better than casting to dead water. You can’t make fish bite, but you can fish the right places, which greatly increases you odds..

    As far as the release part, I also hope you are correct…

    jd318
    NE Nebraska
    Posts: 757
    #849160

    Quote:


    …size is a BIG DEAL.


    What?!? I was told size doesn’t matter! Oh, your talking about screen size, nevermind.

    kris_brantner
    My river
    Posts: 1678
    #849167

    no one sence the sarcasam??????? i have the 997. i paid 1200 for mine i have had alot of fun with mine and learned a bunch of great areas with it. im just mad that pretty much everyone has one now

    Tom P.
    Whitehall Wi.
    Posts: 3526
    #849520

    Quote:


    no one sence the sarcasam??????? i have the 997. i paid 1200 for mine i have had alot of fun with mine and learned a bunch of great areas with it. im just mad that pretty much everyone has one now


    Not me usually the more of one product built and sold the cheaper for the rest of us. Or at least good used units.

    DougV
    Posts: 8
    #849885

    Side Imaging is a Time Management Tool in my opinion. No matter if your a recreational angler, guide or the best competitive angler we are all limited on the amount of time we can spend on the water. Our Number 1 Goal is to catch more fish in that amount of time whether it is one hour a week or 10 hours of competition in a day. Maximizing your time in the most productivity waters to have the highest odds of catching more fish is what Side Imaging can do for you. I want every odd in my favor that is why I choose the boat I run, the tackle, the rods, reels and baits to be the best I can be for that allotted period of time. Side Imaging is probably the greatest tool any angler can invest in help put him in the most productive areas and increase his odds of catching more fish. Side Imaging doesn’t make the fish open their mouths but it sure helps me find where they live. Once I find where they it makes it easier for me to figure out what makes them bite versus hunting for where they live. And yes it has drastically increased my catch ratio.

    whittsend
    Posts: 2389
    #850271

    Doug – Very nice synopsis, and welcome to IDO!!

    theodorenugget
    Sugar Land, TX
    Posts: 609
    #850395

    Not to mention a saver in gas by being able to cover so much water.

Viewing 28 posts - 1 through 28 (of 28 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.