Vikefan,
Good eye! I see what you see….that is not a chubby darter. I use couple different rigs that some may scoff at, but I will explain.
The chubby darter you see is actually one of those “keel” weight type sinkers that looks like a gold side black back minnow. They also come in a white shiner looking minnow in various weights. I like them even though they are off set a bit because they look “real”…well sort of…how about they look natural. I usually combo that up with a hand tied 7 strand leader about 3 to 4 feet long with a circle hook and that’s it. I just started using circle hooks a couple years ago, but they work and the fish can be released unharmed. It also is a much better finesse looking presentation. These pike don’t get to be 40 to dare I say 50 inches in length by being stupid or ignoring ridiculous tangles of hooks and kinked wire with a smallish sucker attached to it… That said, the second pic is just the keel weight with a Northland Tackle quick strike rig…yes the spinners add some flash! Nice Taz! The other reason I like the “keel” weight is the weight. When using BIG baits I want to pin that bait as much as I can without going to heavy. In other words, decrease its ability to evade a curious monster pike! If the minnow can shoot up 10 feet because it’s only got a couple slit shot nearby, the pike might decide to pass…as in Oh well I wasn’t that hungry anyway. I Know, I know, plenty of big pike are caught on basic rigs. I also know that quick strike rigs can be effective at hooking and releasing fish unharmed IF you can get to them quick. Lots of ways to do it…I am just a guy who like to fish too much.
Shoot, I am rambling…sorry. These are only my thoughts as I approach catching these beauties! I don’t claim to be an expert, but I’ve caught a few.