Chris,
I live in town, and Verizon works just fine for me, everywhere. there was a dead spot by applebees, oreilly’s, the bar, that area right there, but it was fixed last year sometime. I have zero dead spots anywhere in town, and my phone now gets full service all around welch, treasure island, red wing, even in the hills around welch and vasa, i get excellent signal for the most part.
I have had verizon for 7+ years now as my personal phone. I have always gotten superior overall reception, versus any other carrier in the remote areas.
I have had AT&T, Sprint, and T-Mobile blackberry’s for work.
AT&T was fine in the metro, ok in the rural, not close to the verizon signal though.
Sprint: was pretty close to verizon for rural signal, but i got stronger signal with my verizon phone, and areas my sprint phone got nothing, i usually had reception with verizon.
T-Mobile: Great in the metro, absolutely worthless in rural if you are off of a major highway/freeway.
Sprint was hands down the best in Western wisconsin though. if i spent a lot of time over there, i would probably have a sprint phone.
just recently i gave my work phone back, and am using my verizon account for work. using google voice on my Droid Incredible.
there are other reasons besides cell reception that i like verizon.
better customer service IMHO, much much better 3G internet coverage, better phone selections, especially for the droid phones.
and when Verizon’s LTE 4G service goes active this late fall/early winter, holy crap, lookout! this service is capable of carrying up to 100mb service! it is leaps and bounds ahead of sprint’s 4G service.
i currently average 1mb+ download rates on my droid with just 3G, and it works all over. I was able to stream audio for the Twins games this past weekend on the north shore with my phone!
also chris, i would not go with the Hero, it is old technology. get one of the newer droid phones. if you go with Verizon, there are a few new ones out right now. If you want, i can show you in person my Droid Incredible, so you can see how fast, and how good these phones are, plus the things they are capable of.