wow!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • john_steinhauer
    p4
    Posts: 2998
    #1267773

    got this in my e mail today anyone else see it yet i think anyone would be happy to get this one

    Did you hear about the 4 1/2 -pound crappie?
    To Wisconsin fisherman, this is no ordinary fish story
    Mike Zimmer was enjoying a phenomenal morning of crappie fishing. Then, it nearly turned historic.
    The 33-year-old angler from Menomonie was fishing a lake in Menomonie on March 15 when he hooked a 4 pound, 5 ounce white crappie.
    “It was unbelievable,” Zimmer said. “It’s probably like catching an 8- or 9-pound bass or a 70-pound flathead (catfish). Crappie fisherman know just how big something like this is.”
    The behemoth that measured 19 inches long and had a girth of 16 inches was part of a crappie bonanza for Zimmer. He started fishing that chilly morning — the temperature was about 40 degrees — at 7:20 a.m.
    By 10:30 a.m., he was already at the dock with his limit of 25 crappie. Among the keepers were a 3-pounder and one that weighed 3 pounds, 8 ounces.
    The previous day, Zimmer also caught his limit of 25 in under four hours. That’s why he declined to reveal the name of the lake that harbors his crappie honeyhole.
    “Next thing you know, they’ll be people all over the place fishing for crappie,” Zimmer said with a laugh.
    Clad in his thermal duck hunting clothes, Zimmer was one of the few fishermen on the lake that morning. The nippy temperatures didn’t faze Zimmer, who said he has been fishing since he was in diapers.
    “For me, I’ve always caught my bigger ones early when it was cold,” he said. “For most people, they would not even go on a day like that. It wasn’t ideal by any means, but it was for me.”
    Zimmer was using a 12-foot crappie pole outfitted with 4-pound test and a slip cork. His bait of choice was a Grizzly jig tipped with a small minnow. Knowing the crappie were preparing to spawn, he was fishing in shallow water (between 2 and 10 feet) around some downed trees.
    It didn’t take long for Zimmer to realize he had landed on a school of crappie. Big ones, too.
    “I had beaten my own personal record (3 pounds) on the 12th or 13th keeper of the day,” Zimmer said. “The 4.5-pounder was the 23rd keeper. I knew I only had three more fish to go, and here I catch this one.”
    When he hooked it, Zimmer didn’t think it was a crappie.
    “I’m thinking that’s a catfish because it stayed down low,” he said. “It didn’t want to come up. A muskie will do the same thing. They’ll put a good fight up and not come up to the surface. After a little bit of fighting I started to see it, and I realized it was a crappie. All I could think of was that 4-pound test breaking, because I knew it was a big one. I don’t know how long I fought it because all I was thinking was getting it in the boat.”
    Once he landed the papermouth, he collapsed into his seat due to a combination of exhaustion and excitement over his catch. After he caught his breath, Zimmer weighed the crappie on a hand-held scale. It came in just under 4.5 pounds.
    Zimmer then had the fish weighed on certified scales at the Millstadt post office and a butcher’s shop in Sparta . The fish is currently at a taxidermist, where Zimmer plans to have it mounted.
    Coming oh-so-close to breaking a 37-year-old record didn’t seem to bother Zimmer, who is a chemical operator at a plant in East St. Louis .
    “It might even be better than catching the state record because I might have gotten more publicity than I wanted,” Zimmer said. “Then, I would have really had to give up my spot.”
    News of Zimmer’s near-record catch has been making the rounds.
    “My brother, who lives in Waltonville, had someone come up to him saying ‘Man, did you hear about this dude that caught a 4.5-pound, 3.5-pound and 3.25-pound crappie?'” Zimmer said. “He’s like ‘Yeah, I did. I seen them because he’s my brother.’ I guess news like that gets around pretty quick.”


    mplspug
    Palmetto, Florida
    Posts: 25026
    #875350

    Not to nitpick…well yes, to nitpick. That is not the way to measure the length. You bend a tape measure around the length of a 16″ girth crappie with tape measure and it is not going to be accurate. Might only be off by a half inch or so, but I did preface this with I was nitpicking.

    That is a monster regardless. I give it 3 exclamation point and a half. !!!.

    whittsend
    Posts: 2389
    #875351

    I got that one too…. I smell a fish story….

    (Was the ice even out on March 15 in Menomonie???? I doubt it….)

    Wade Boardman
    Grand Rapids, MN
    Posts: 4453
    #875352

    Quote:


    Not to nitpick…well yes, to nitpick. That is not the way to measure the length. You bend a tape measure around the length of a 16″ girth crappie with tape measure and it is not going to be accurate. Might only be off by a half inch or so, but I did preface this with I was nitpicking.

    That is a monster regardless. I give it 3 exclamation point and a half. !!!.


    MPLSPUG, I got this e-mail as well. I had trouble getting past the fact that this……………………..person killed a number of monster crappie. I guess some people are fans of freezers full of fish.

    pool13_jeff
    NW, IL
    Posts: 884
    #875354

    That same fish has been caught in at least 3 different states. They even use the same picture.

    targaman
    Inactive
    Wilton, WI
    Posts: 2759
    #875355

    Last I heard it came out of Illinois…

    suzuki
    Woodbury, Mn
    Posts: 18605
    #875356

    “He started fishing that chilly morning — the temperature was about 40 degrees — at 7:20 a.m.
    By 10:30 a.m., he was already at the dock with his limit of 25 crappie. Among the keepers were a 3-pounder and one that weighed 3 pounds, 8 ounces.
    The previous day, Zimmer also caught his limit of 25 in under four hours. That’s why he declined to reveal the name of the lake that harbors his crappie honeyhole. “

    Ok so he had his limit that day and the day before. Sounds like a poacher or fish hog at the very least. How stupid is it to admit all that!?!?!?!? Losing interest fast…..gone.

    whittsend
    Posts: 2389
    #875357

    Quote:


    That same fish has been caught in at least 3 different states. They even use the same picture.


    I like this quote… “Knowing the crappie were preparing to spawn, he was fishing in shallow water (between 2 and 10 feet) around some downed trees.”

    Crappie spawn is 3 months away in WI, dude…

    Plus, 40 degrees at 7 am is a hot streak (not a “chilly morning” for March 15th in Menomonie…

    targaman
    Inactive
    Wilton, WI
    Posts: 2759
    #875359

    Crappies are in the shallows preparing to spawn in March? Maybe I read it wrong, idk…

    john_steinhauer
    p4
    Posts: 2998
    #875362

    sounds like everyone feels the same way i do but a really nice fish to say the least

    whittsend
    Posts: 2389
    #875364

    Quote:


    sounds like everyone feels the same way i do but a really nice fish to say the least


    TRUE…

    I suppose if I caught a crappie like that, I would have probably said I was fishing in Lake Superior in about 120 f.o.w. with crickets behind a silver/blue dodger going about 12.4 mph behind a Church walleye board….. (And, BTW, you should have seen the ones that go away!!!)

    fieds
    ottertail county
    Posts: 128
    #875386

    that white crappie sure looks black

    Jay Jones
    Onalaska Wi
    Posts: 107
    #845022

    Dedicated fisherman and employee, driving from Menomonie to East St. Louis to work, then the closest scale was in Sparta??? Nice fish, wish we could get the Real story on it.

    whiskeysour
    4 miles from Pool 9
    Posts: 693
    #845023

    I think the whole thing is a hoax.

    1. There is no Millstadt, WI.

    2. Lives in Menomonie but works in East Saint Louis.

    3. Why would he weigh the fish in Sparta?

    4. The bag limit on panfish on Menomin and Tainter Lakes are 10, not 25.

    John Schultz
    Inactive
    Portage, WI
    Posts: 3309
    #875391

    Do a little googling and you can find that fish caught all over the place.

    Alabama

    Wisconsin

    Illinois

    Take your pick. It’s also been caught in Missouri, but I can’t find that story.

    Chris
    Rochester, MN
    Posts: 1396
    #875395

    Great fish… Even better if the story was true.

    I think there are too many exclamation marks for the thread title… it’s skewing the page

    85lund
    Menomonie, WI
    Posts: 2317
    #875413

    Quote:


    I got that one too…. I smell a fish story….

    (Was the ice even out on March 15 in Menomonie???? I doubt it….)


    I am pretty sure that is the day we had to have our shacks off the lake and I was driving out to get mine. I don’t remember seeing his boat

    It is funny how a fish story can be spread and FAST. I was out at northwest landing last week talking with a guy landing his boat and he told me about the 19″ crappie caught on Menomonin. It is hard to believe unless you see the picture. I have seen the picture and I now know its BS.

    loshinit420
    Posts: 95
    #875414

    That is a black crappie if I ever seen one, yes a monster and yes a fish that should of been released along with the other giants, I can understand mounting the one or maybe two together but keeping all the big fish caught is not what fishing is all about. Hard to understand why anyone would wanna take those kind of genetics out of they’re secret spot… CATCH AND RELEASE, IT WORKS!!

    red89
    Hudson
    Posts: 918
    #875435

    Now everytime I go to menomin there is gonna be a guy at the landing telling me how his buddy caught a 19 inch crappie out here…

    john_steinhauer
    p4
    Posts: 2998
    #875452

    Quote:


    Now everytime I go to menomin there is gonna be a guy at the landing telling me how his buddy caught a 19 inch crappie out here…


    chriswallace
    Andover, MN
    Posts: 275
    #875461

    A ten fish stringer mount of them would be BA!

    timschmitz
    Waconia MN
    Posts: 1652
    #875490

    This is going to be like that stupid rainy lake pike email (the next person to post that one is fined 3 million fish bucks) I heard this guy was reeling in a small crappie and the 19″er ate the little one

    jon_wbl
    Posts: 289
    #875499

    Quote:


    This is going to be like that stupid rainy lake pike email (the next person to post that one is fined 3 million fish bucks) I heard this guy was reeling in a small crappie and the 19″er ate the little one


    Looks like this guy is everyones brother already.

    Jon Stevens
    Northfield, Wi
    Posts: 1242
    #875644

    I have no info on the fish it’s self but….there is a town of Sparta, Millstadt, and Waltonville. All are south east of St. Louis…..

    docfrigo
    Wisconsin
    Posts: 1564
    #875656

    If there was not a photo of the fish, who would believe it.
    Either a really bad reporter or like a typical fisherman–stretched the truth a little and left out some key facts.
    Looks like a farm pond fish to me–but then again, what a fish!

Viewing 26 posts - 1 through 26 (of 26 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.