Huge pike?

  • mossydan
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa
    Posts: 7727
    #1266330

    This has to do with the flood we got a couple years ago and I have to ask how big do Pike really get. Everybody’s heard stories about the big fish in every species that swim the waters but never seem to get caught…Here’s the story,,, I know a guy here in town that I’ve know since I was 14 years old, I’m now 58, he also use to be manager of Fins and Feathers sporting goods store here plus he use to be on a local trap league and has been on television here with a local sports announcer fishing the areas rivers here for smallies.

    I seen Dan the other day and he told me about a northern they found in a basement of the old ZCBJ girls gym on the southeast side of town and a couple blocks off the river. He said Dan, my names also Dan, he said did you hear about that 42 pound northern they found in the basement there, I said no. He said yes they did and I said are you kidding and he said no, they did find this huge northern there. I had to leave and couldn’t ask anymore questions and If I see him again soon I will.

    Tim another friend of mine who was fishing the backwaters next to the Cedar River here in town said he caught a northern last year that he said went 5 feet long. Up until the time I heard from Dan tell me about that northern I thought Tim just had big fish eyes and was maybe 3 feet long and not the 5 he said it was. Tim said he pulled it up on the bank because his net was too small and the fish threw the Mepps spinner so he jumped on it and it still got away and slid back into the water. He was using my catfish rod and reel I use for flat heads and re-spooled it with 30 pound line, I had 45 on it, because he was catching quiet a few big pike that week in the same spot and didn’t want to loose anymore so he went to bigger line, bigger then his spinning rods. Tim has seen his share of nice pike but one 5′ long and Dans report of that 42 pound northern, it really makes a guy think if it is possible because we hear of those solitary big fish in each species, what do you guys think? Think its possible?

    I did see a huge walleye about 15 years ago here on the south side of town at the mouth of a local creek. I waded out to the mouth where the sand ledge was and fell into deeper water into the river. When I waded in the water I knew right away it was too warm to hold walleyes and I think smallies too but I still waded out to the mouth right on the river. I was standing there watching the water clearity move back and forth, the clean creek water would move back and forth revealing the drop off and what it might hold there in fish. I was watching the water move when this huge walleye came into the warmer creek water for a few seconds then moved back out into the cooler water of the river and it was gone. I got a good look at it and I remember seeing the size of it and it didn’t fit into the realm of other big walleyes I’ve seen, it was much bigger.

    Too tell you how big this walleye was, well its bigger then any walleye I’ve even seen anywhere and was several pounds bigger then any 12 to 14 lb’er I’ve seen on any wall and to make an eye size comparison, its eyes were the size of a Susan B Anthony silver dollar. It was pounds bigger then anything I’ve ever seen so I know without a doubt there’s huge walleyes around. I know there’s big fish around that are rarely caught and very rarely seen, What do you guys think, think its possible?

    putt2winn
    Eau Claire, WI
    Posts: 233
    #846969

    To much they need more

    mossydan
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa
    Posts: 7727
    #846973

    Both of these guys don’t drink.

    putt2winn
    Eau Claire, WI
    Posts: 233
    #846981

    No offence was implied. I am sorry if it was taken wrong. In my opinion, possible but 60″ not likely. Like most fish tales I like pics.

    DaveB
    Inver Grove Heights MN
    Posts: 4558
    #846994

    One pike swallowed Jonah, but then Noah pulled it onto his lead ark and pulled Johah out. When Noah released the mighty beast, all its teeth fell out (since it was summer) and it turned into a green sunfish as it hit the water.

    mossydan
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa
    Posts: 7727
    #847030

    I know what your saying Putt, those are big fish and definitely pushing the limits. Its kind of like by the time 6 people hear the story its twice the size that it actually was, but the walleye description is true, I seen it myself.

    hairjig
    Cudahy, Wis.
    Posts: 936
    #847033

    Unless I see dated pictures of the supposed fish “I don’t believe any of it, talk is cheap, show me the money”………

    Steve Plantz
    SE MN
    Posts: 12239
    #847045

    Quote:


    Unless I see dated pictures of the supposed fish “I don’t believe any of it, talk is cheap, show me the money”………


    X2

    sliderfishn
    Blaine, MN
    Posts: 5431
    #847054

    I believe that there are fish swimming that never get caught or seen by people, some monster size fish as well.

    I have made many trips to DNR stripping stations when I was growing up, volunteering to help in anyway that I could. One day the phone rings at my house and it was Woody Sherman, a DNR conservation officer in the Brainerd area. He told me that I, along with my dad, needed to come down that the Pine River stripping station to see something. We make the drive in a few minutes and ask Woody what is it that was so urgent. It turns out that they netted a monster walleye that would break the state record. I got to hold this behemoth while they stripped her eggs into the collection bucket. That walleye had never been caught in those stripping nets before. While she never weighted as much as she did the first year she was caught, she did return for three more years, donating her eggs and fantastic genes with each journey. She was never seen after that. I suppose that she died from old age. If she was caught I and you would have heard about it, hard to keep quiet a 19+ pound walleye.

    Ron

    Brian Hoffies
    Land of 10,000 taxes, potholes & the politically correct.
    Posts: 6843
    #847061

    There are giant fish out there we don’t see. That said 60″ seems a bit abnormal. As for you picture guys take a trip to the Muskie sites. As they battle over every picture of a huge fish when posted it makes me positive I would never post a photo there. They will tell you it’s the angle, the fish is partly in the shade, the guy was stretching his arms, it was photo shopped bla, bla, bla……………

    Seeing is truly believing and in the case of big fish I just wanna see them.

    shaley
    Milford IA
    Posts: 2178
    #847081

    60″ is rare for even a muskie let alone a pike, biggest pike I ever witnessed was 48″ and scaled at 27 pounds. Was 3rd biggest pike registered in Ontario that year. 50″ seems to be the mark most pike chasers dream of, those are as rare as a 60″ muskie maybe even more so. 42″ is the biggest Iowa pike I have seen and she only scaled 17 pounds.

    For perspective this is a 52″ muskie 41 pounds.

    mossydan
    Cedar Rapids, Iowa
    Posts: 7727
    #847150

    I hear you Guys and this is from a level headed frame of mind but I’ve caught pike bigger then the 15 pound mark around here. Here’s a story,,, I picked up a couple younger guys in their late 20’s hitch-hiking on a road because their car broke down. We got to talking and I asked what they were doing and they said pike fishing. I asked where abouts it was and they described it and I knew where it was. I told them I run lines there for catfish during warmer water and I knew that it had a mud bottom so I knew the area. Its rock and sand above and below this mud flat area and I’ve dropped anchor all over this area so I knew it was the only one around. This was about early march and the ice was gone below the dam here all the way down to this area and past it but before the spring melt took place when the water comes up. I then asked do you ever get any nice ones and they said yes and then I said how big are they and I remember it vividly, He said they have pictures in the Marion bait shop, locally, of 20 pounder’s on the wall in the photo section and that they have lost fish because of their line breaking that were bigger then that. I have caught alot of nice pike around here with some close to 15 pounds so it really didn’t surprise me when they told me that.

    I do know where this mud flat is and I can see the pike wintering over in this spot because of the food base that moves into that area in winter. In a few local creeks when the water warms up the quillback come up into the creeks and the majority are around a pound in weight and the deeper waters around this area is where the pike are feeding on them.

    In the winter the quillback leave the creek and because their mollusk and worm feeders I’m pretty sure they move up river about 3/4rs of a mile to this mud flat and winter over there and the northerns follow. All the water around this area has enough current in winter to make the pike move into this slower water area of this mud flat and with the quillback there they can feed when they need to all winter. I’m convinced that most of the pike in this 2 miles long stretch of river move into this area and feed during winter. Slower water during winter plus forage = bigger fish and I have no reason to disbelieve these two guys. I’ve been in the Marion bait shop dozens of times and if they said their pictures were on the wall I believe them, I could tell these two guys knew what they were talking about. I do know that there are some big pike around these parts so when I’m told by a couple other guys I’ve known for along time that these fish do exist I tend to believe them or atleast listen. They have some monster flatheads around here so why not big pike too, maybe its time to float my jonboat down to this spot and throw a few big spinners early in the spring after the ice thaws and before the spring thaw comes, It has to be the place where they winter over because everything around this area is shallow and I do know there’s alot of pike in this stretch of the river.

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.