You need to look at the numbers on your current prop. There will be a series of numbers followed buy a 2 digit number and a “P”. (The “P” stands for pitch.) That 2 digit number will be 11, 12, 13 or 14 for that motor. In other words you are running some where in the 11 to 14 pitch range. If you were generally satisfied with the current props performance, stay with the same pitch.
The other number you need to know is “Diameter”. The diameter for your prop will be 10 ½ (Ten and one half or 10.5) That number will not change. You cannot go bigger or smaller.
So, when you go shopping you will be looking for a 10.5 x 12p prop assuming you find that the pitch number on your current prop is 12. (And 12 is a very common pitch for that motor.)
If you feel that your current prop should be turning more RPM’s, drop the pitch one number. If you feel that the prop is spinning to fast, go up one number. Again, if you felt the motor ran well, go with the same pitch. That goes for both stainless and aluminum in that 50hp range.
I have found that the Cabelas store brand props perform well and would buy another if I needed to.
Good Luck,
-J.