It completely depends on time of year, what body of water and what kind of forage is available. If you’re looking for my favorite one to use (favorite way to catch them), it’s always going to be lures that I make myself. This could be crawler harnesses, some of my hand carved crankbaits, modified cranks or spinner blades. I enjoy every fish that I catch on a lure that I tinkered with or made twice as much as one I catch on a crankbait I just pulled out of the box.
I have favorites for pretty much every presentation I use. I will list them below.
Spring/Fall Rivers – Small jigs with Ringworms
Summer Rivers – Trolling Shad Raps/Wally Divers/Mean-Streaks or casting cranks
Summer Open Water Trolling – Reef Runners, Hand made crawler harnesses, or Streak Freaks
Summer Jigging – Big bulky swim baits
Late Fall/Early Spring on the river – three way with a stick bait slowly up stream
Ice Walleyes – Jigging Rapala, Buckshot spoon, Go Devil etc…
Pretty much any of these can be used at any of the other times, it’s just the how and where that each person has to figure out. Good luck.