If you go to a 19, you will drop your RPM’s by about 200-300. At your current RPM, you don’t want to drop any further. A 19p prop would likely feel like a dog of a prop.
A 4-blade prop will generally give you more bow lift and more “hook up” in turns. Generally better hole shot. You will lose a little top end on a 4-blade of the same pitch.
Go to your dealer and see if they have a loaner prop program. Try out a 3 and a 4 blade stainless in both a 15 and 17 pitch. Dropping to a 15 pitch will increase your RPMs to the upper end of the power range. You want to find the right match with pitch and RPM’s running near max.
You will know when you find the right prop. Motor will sing and boat will handle like a jet ski!
-J.