I was hoping to do this last year but winter didn’t really show up and give me much of a chance to try them out, this year has given me plenty of opportunities. I put a set of Blizzaks on my F150 and a set of General Arctics on my focus.
The Blizzaks are very good on wet icy roads but the tread pattern isn’t as open as I would like for heavy snow covered roads. The Generals have a more open pattern that is better on the snow and still does pretty good on ice.
I like the compound of the Blizzaks a little better, the Generals seem a little stiffer in the cold weather. I liked the more open tread on the Generals. I would prefer the Blizzak tire with a more open tread design for the heavy snow days.
I know the tires were on very different vehicles but I compared it to how both vehicles handled on their previous all season tires. Next year I think I am going to try a set of Michelin snows and see how they handle, I’ve heard some good things on those tires.
Overall dedicated winter tires seemed to make a big difference over the all season tires that were on each vehicle.