portable sheds–poly vs metal

  • superiorfishing
    Hastings,MN
    Posts: 395
    #1281401

    looking at putting up a shed for my 20ft boat this springs without spending alot–well right there answers my questions–they poly tarped sided one is must cheaper–like around $400–but in long run if you have to replaced that tarp once dont you have one of those metal pole portable shed paid for?? I think they run like $1300 for size i looking for 10’h x 10’w x 25′ L and thoughts–thanks

    1hl&sinker
    On the St.Croix
    Posts: 2501
    #1156128

    Are you going to have the sides go all the way down if so keep in mind if its fully enclosed its going to get hot and humid in there if you go plastic. If the plastic is uv rated like green houses the plastic should last a long time easy 10 years. Reinforced polly goes around $7 a lineal ft for twenty ft wide for replacement quality green house polly for hoop greenhouses.

    Neusch1
    Posts: 18
    #1156130

    I have a Versatube for my 20ft skeeter and it was $2400 at Menards

    kooty
    Keymaster
    1 hour 15 mins to the Pond
    Posts: 18101
    #1156132

    My parents had a poly tarp style on the farm in South Dakota. Didn’t last two years. The wind out there ate it up.

    TheFamousGrouse
    St. Paul, MN
    Posts: 11658
    #1156156

    Don’t do it man. That poly crap will be nothing but a hassle. The UV from the sun eats that poly so it’s just a matter of if it lasts 1 year or 2 at most.

    Do the metal with at least the sides that extend halfway down at least.

    Be sure to check to see if your town has ordinances that restrict structures like this.

    Grouse

    superiorfishing
    Hastings,MN
    Posts: 395
    #1156176

    am putting it up north at cabin so i dont have to tarp the boat after each time i go fishing and leave again—i thought i can start with metal and with top for sure and as time goes add on the sides and if it portable its ok to put up without taxes and all that going up or permit needed–i was wondering about the snow and branches also busting up the poly ones–thanks for input

    mbenson
    Minocqua, Wisconsin
    Posts: 3842
    #1156254

    s.fishing:

    I am currently in my third winter with my poly from Menards, appprox. $400 in silver. It is a humidity creation machine. Once it starts to get warm enough here this spring, I will be opening up the front panels to allow air access to prevent humidity build-up. During the winter, in order to get snow off the top, I have to tarp the boat (just cover and shake ice off) or the frozen water droplets on the inside all land inside the boat while I am pushing snow off of it.

    Another minor issue is water from spring runoff running through the structure. It does not create any rutting damage. I am sure with one of two fixes that would not be an issue.

    Make sure you put it in a place where it won’t restrict your movement. I was in after wood later this winter, got stuck just off my drive and while attempting to get it out, backed into it with the truck’s hitch and poked a hole in it. I will be using duct tape to repair it.

    You cannot buy a replacement tarp for the specific package, you must buy the entire package including the frame again.

    I also wasn’t sure what my status was in my current location, so I didn’t use the anchors to permanently cement it in place. I have been thinking about making a circle drive and a drive through second garage for my boat and other toys.

    I have a friend who is using the same one to store his boat in it and built in shelving along the top from bars which is kind of a nice feature.

    I was concerned about the wind blowing it away, but it seems that the biggest concerns I have had are snow caving it in and humidity formation and the frozen droplets.

    Mark

    AllenW
    Mpls, MN
    Posts: 2895
    #1156309

    I bought the same shed menards uses for their carts in the parking lot, works great and unlike the tarp ones I’ve had, take a licking and keep on protecting.

    Al

    superiorfishing
    Hastings,MN
    Posts: 395
    #1156418

    yeah i want one that you put up with metal roof for starters and put sides on as time goes on—menards sells those too dont they?? i dont get there enough to know if they do or not–if not were can you get these metal ones at?? thanks

    williekutz
    Member
    Posts: 1
    #1369176

    Ordinarily putting cash on hand crafted sheds at your home or office suite can truly demonstrate as the best venture alternative. After all you add values to your property, which give rich returns when you offer or give the space on rent.

    superiorfishing
    Hastings,MN
    Posts: 395
    #1369615

    I had to take a double check here–no not a discount double check either!! seem this posting was from spring–I did go with a metal Menards shelter and loving it!!

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.