Wow, I just went through the same debate. My Etec 50 is a tiller without a tach. I damaged the factory prop, which was a 13-3/4 x 13 aluminum. I went to a 13-3/4 x 15 aluminum. I would have loved to go higher, but without a tach I chickened out. Like the guys said, I gained 4-5 MPH on the top end and lost hole shot. Good luck. cheers