If your old prop works fine, (satisfactory hole shot, gas milage, upper end speed and hitting target RPM), I wouldn’t change anything unless you have a specific problem.
Save the money for a new rod or something.
I doubt you’d gain a whole heck of a lot of performance from a new prop, unless you current prop isn’t the right diameter/pitch for your rig. Stainless will maybe gain you 1-2 mph, but you’ll pay for it. (it will be less prone to dings and such, though, and hole shot might be better with stainless vs aluminum)
Aluminum will cost probably $100+
Stainless can run $300-$800.
If you decide to change, work with a shop who will let you test drive all the props on your rig. Log your hole shots, upper end speeds, RPM’s, etc vs which pitch/diameter/composition (SS vs AL)…
It can be a pain, but who knows – maybe you have the time and will enjoy doing the testing. If you do it, good luck… But if your current prop is working fine for you, you might want to consider saving some time and $$.
That being said, if you don’t have a spare prop, its always good to have one. You could use this opportunity to test out new props and use your old one as a backup when/if you find a new one that works for you.
I wouldn’t expect massive results though, more like very minor improvements, if any… Probably won’t be hitting 50mph or anything like that….
2 cents.