Ok. In through the nose, and out through the mouth….
All of this attention, and talk about what is going on in and around Lake Mille Lacs got me to thinking I really need to research the Treaties of 1837, and 1855. Article 9 of the 1855 Treaty states, and I quote:”The said bands of Indians, jointly and severally, obligate and bind themselves not to commit any depredations or wrong upon other Indians, OR UPON CITIZENS OF THE UNITED STATES; to conduct themselves at all times in a peaceful and orderly manner; to submit all difficulties between them and other Indians to the President, and abide by his decision in regards to the same, and to RESPECT AND OBSERVE THE LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES, so far as the same to them applicable. And they also stipulate that they will settle down in the peaceful pursuits of life, commence to the cultivation of soil, and appropriate their means to the errection of houses, opening farms, the education of their children, and such other objects of improvement and convenience, AS ARE INCIDENT TO A WELL REGULATED SOCIETY; and that they will abstain from the use of intoxicating drinks and other vices to which they have been addicted.”
In through the nose, out through the mouth…..
Observation #1.
We Americans have LAWS and REGULATIONS specific to taking of game and fish across this nation. I found no granting of rights, or quotas on the amount of fish and game that is guaranteeing the Indians ANYTHING! There are roughly 2600 tribesman and women practicing the netting and spearing in lakes within their domain in the ceded territory. On the other hand, there are 1.2 million sportsmen and women in Minnesota alone who are held to a much tighter standard. There are 1.2 million incidences where Americans “Rights” are being violated. It is apparent to me that the Indians are not respecting the laws of the United States in this respect. Why can’t the quota be pro-rated based on the number of people actually excercising their rights? 1.2 million vs. 2600. Do the math.
Observation # 2.
To me, the “Peaceful pursuits of life” does not mean taking walleye and other game fish in large quantities for commercial purposes, where normal Americans cannot. If they want to net. Go ahead. They can have 6 fish per day, and they can only be from 14 to 16 inches, and one over 28 inches. The rest must be returned back to the water unharmed! How long do you think they will continue to net based on the limits we are held to? Again, it is the “Law of the United State’s” that apply to them as well as us.
Observation #3
The last part of Article 9 makes reference to making adjustments to living in a “Well Regulated Society” Well folks, a well regulated society means “Regulations”, Rules, Laws, etc. If they want to net fish…fine. But, there are REGULATIONS, 6 fish per day, 14-16″, and 1 over 28″. They want to shoot deer…fine, one per person, and no taking of does without a permit. Shooting at night is illegal. We have REGULATIONS prohibiting it.
I think I have made my point. If you all get a chance, look up the Treaties of 1837 and 1855. You can come up with your own interpretations…
Tuck

Guest
Posts:
August 19, 2002 at 4:01 pm
#259254