I left an inline of mine uncleaned and the bore got really, really rusty. I worked a bronze brush through it many, many times with penetrating oil and got most of the rust out. The barrel was pitted. I thought the gun was ruined. It is a Knight Muzzleloader, with Green Mountain barrel. I had good mounts and rings on it and a decent although not super high dollar 3-9×40 scope and had witnesses when I shot a 3 shot clover leaf at 200 yards off a bench of course. Well I had my gunsmith look at it and he said it was safe so I shot it. It was still a shooter! It takes longer to clean now, but is still a serviceable ML. Keep in mind, the trigger mechanism, safety system, and the like were not rusted. So perhaps clean it up, and then have it examined by a competent gunsmith and let them decide. I will say this, and no offense is intended. Those Green Mountain barrels are really high quality steel. The CVAs, especially the older ones, not so much. So please do get professional opinion. How hard was it to get the breech plug out? Are the breech plug threads corroded? That would worry me. Mine were not, and probably because I coat all of my breech plugs with anti-seize.