Fish ID help

  • Marc Robson
    Posts: 4
    #2141309

    Learning to fish at spring river in Arkansas. In the morning I keep spotting very large fish slowly surfacing. Like 18″ or more.

    I see a flat face and then the dorsal fin and slowly then a second dorsal fin and finally the tail fin. Emphasizing how slowly this fish breeches

    It’s a darker colored fish.

    Sometimes it seems like a second one right behind it. And it often repeats in roughly the same spot. I am not 100% positive but seems like it is facing upstream mostly.

    Ed Mashburn
    Posts: 26
    #2141336

    Good evening to all-
    Well, brother, there in the Spring River of north Arkansas I would be willing to bet that you’re seeing carp of some kind rolling. they do that sort of thing, and I can’t think of anything else that fits your description.
    There are loads of trout in that flow, and even some quite good walleyes.
    I’m betting on carp that you see.

    you all be safe and keep well- Ed

    Dave Lozier
    Amherst, WI
    Posts: 957
    #2141338

    Pictures would probably help?

    Matt Moen
    South Minneapolis
    Posts: 4268
    #2141341

    Definitely snook. Or possibly a green sunfish.

    Marc Robson
    Posts: 4
    #2141344

    I google carp and i think you are correct. They are described as bottom dwellers and jumpers though and those dont quite match up with what I am seeing (jumping sounds switfy and these seem so slow and lazy, but the face looks right).

    Videos implies corn or balls of bread so will give that a shot and see if I can confirm

    Thanks Ed !

    Craig Sery
    Bloomington, MN
    Posts: 1204
    #2141394

    Good luck, fun fish to catch!

    Jon Jordan
    Keymaster
    St. Paul, Mn
    Posts: 6019
    #2141398

    Gar maybe?

    -J.

    mann4ducks
    Posts: 235
    #2141447

    I would go with Gar. We have a place just south of Mountain Home AR and my parents live there now. Great location tremendous lakes and rivers. Within an hour of MH. Haven’t found any ice or large perch there yet So staying in CO for awhile more. although good eyes and warm water fish along with great river fly fishing below the dams.

    Marc Robson
    Posts: 4
    #2141500

    Pretty sure it’s not gar although I do see a lot. Face is flat which I think is the funny mouth carp have. As opposed to the long skinny gar snout

    Pailofperch
    Central Mn North of the smiley water tower
    Posts: 2918
    #2141504

    Carp will school up and skim the surface for hours on end in some lakes and rivers. Not unusual behavior at all for them.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.