I guess it’s never too early to start this topic every year, (if you search “first ice” on IDO you get 4,180 results). My group is trying to decide between a pre-Christmas LOTW trip or mid-January. I realize there are many trade-offs, and weather is the prime consideration, but that aside what would you guys recommend?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6f194/6f1945449d344baabf61ee77ef8a5964e42d028b" alt=""
Posts: 461