I’d be aweful surprised if you can’t fit another bilge in a 17.6 boat, there has to be room! Even if it is mounted further forward than a traditional pump. If it is only for back up then having it a few feet forward would be just fine.
I’d say to go full out and get yourself a 1200 GPH. Your talking about piece of mind. If you go to somethign smaller than you originally figured you might always second guess yourself. Be sure that whatever size you choose that you also use the correct I.D. plumbing to make use of the pumps ability.
I have an automatic bilge (via float switch) and will not have it anyother way. My boat is older and needs the livewell lines replaced. In the meatime they let water into the hull. Combine that with rain when on a several day trip and it is easy to get a lot of water in the boat. With the auto matic bilge the little bugger is down there all night making sure my rig is still floating in the morning. Maybe this is the year I replace those pesky livewell lines. When I do get around to it I will be installing a larger bilge pump too. It just seems a good idea.