I got a new Lund 2 years ago and was very seriously considering a vinyl floor. After looking at numerous used boats, I saw their vinyl floors typically had many cuts, tears, dents, rips and holes. I also like to mount/fasten things on the floor and did not want screw holes in the vinyl whenever I decided to move things around.
I ended up getting a charcoal gray carpet and am still very please with its ease of cleaning and ability to hide dirt. For messy fishermen, I think the charcoal gray carpet is better than any other carpet color currently available.
Dave Gulczinski