I think the only aluminum tiller that really compares to a glass boat is the Lund Pro Guide.
That being said, if you go tiller, fiberglass is really the way to go in terms of staying relatively dry and a smoother ride that tracks well. Really no comparison.
I think all the good glass tillers have been mentioned above – a matter of personal preference and layout. The one recent entry into the market that is missing is Larson. They have 17 and 20 foot tillers and are introducing a 16 foot tiller at the boat show in Mpls next week.
I’m multi-species but partial to bass and like the floor plan that allows you to lay rods on both sides of the boat for easy access and switching out rods and presentations. Skeeter, Larson and Warrior make great boats but don’t have that lay out. I personally don’t like rods laying all over the boat, or having to go in/out of a rod locker every time you switch baits. Backtroller and Yarcraft do have the side shelves, so if I were to drop the money today it would probably be on the latter. Again, that is just my personal preference.