Actually I think oil is part of the problem, the other part being running Either Yamaha’s ring free or I prefer Seafoam myself, every tank of gas to help keep carbon at bay, it seems a little expensive at first, but not when you look at it the long run.
I’ve run YamaLube < Amsoil < Pennzoil semisynthetic/full synthetic I can say my motor runs as good, and the reccomendation came from a trusted motor builder, who also specifically does not like Amsoil. IIRC He likes Merc. oil and Pennzoil.
I can also say carbon wise, even running Seafoam or Ringfree in every tank, my prop is cleaner and darn near carbon free, which I never witnessed with Yamalube or Amsoil.
Also though not a big factor, but a nice one, Pennzoil semi is really reasonable at Walmart, probably half the price of Amsoil.
Online I’ve seen a lot of motors blow with Yamalube, now it’s hard to pin that directly on Yamalube for lots of reasons, but can’t recall a Yamaha motor blown with Pennzoil, I’m sure there are some, at very least something to think about.
As with any oil thread your thoughts and feelings may differ,but it wasn’t a decision that I made lightly, and spent way more time reading up on stuff than I care to admit to.
I also spent a lot of time reading up on saltwater motor forum’s and it gets a big thumbs up from the people I could find, and those guys put some major hours on their boats and motor.