We are crossing in Baudette next week and just not sure of the process. We would be buying a few cases and maybe a bottle. Or is it just easier to buy it actually in canada?
Okay, first we have to know how many people over the age of 21 constitute “we”? That’s what determines what is or is not worthwhile.
EACH adult over 21 can bring 1 liter of spirits (technically it’s 1.14 liters, but WTF?) OR (bizarrely) 1.5 liters of wine OR 24 cans of beer (12 oz cans) into Canada as their duty-free allowance.
So it’s only “worth it” to even consider the duty-free shops if you’re planning to take more than the duty-free amount per person and even then, it’s only a savings for the amount that you are going to go OVER you per-person allowance.
I think this is where the duty-free shops make all their money because guys think buying all the alcohol at the duty-free joint somehow saves them more money.
Secondly, whether or not the duty-free shop is a good deal depends on the prices compared to your local Costco, Cub Liquor, or whatever. In some cases, it’s cheaper to buy say a good bottle of scotch at a Total Wine and then declare it and pay the duty/tax than it is to buy it from the duty-free. This is often true at airports, the prices I see there are no deal even without paying duty.
To add confusion to all this, it depends on which province you’re crossing into because some provinces like Sask have INSANE provincial taxes on alcohol that are added on top of the Canadian-wide VAT and duty.
Good example here, my father was in Costco liquor by his winter home in AZ and he ran into some Canadian guys he knew from the housing development. These guys were in a heated discussion with the liquor store manager because they were trying to buy 10 cases of Crown at really good sale price. They were trying to buy the whole stack that the Costco had. So dad asked them what the deal was because he thought they couldn’t take it back with them to Canada anyway. Not true! These guys were both from Sask and they drive down, but they go back through Alberta because the PST on liquor is lower. They declare and have to pay duty plus vat plus PST, but even that came out to be about $20 CAN a bottle cheaper than they could get it in Sask.
But ON has lower taxes, so going into ON the savings for duty free is probably minimal and there may be no savings at all depending on the base price of the liquor or beer you’re buying.