Does it make sense to use scents?

  • Jim Block
    Posts: 60
    #1472230

    Hello fellow fishermen/women!
    I am new to the forums, but am excited to be part of the outdoor forum community. I’ve used forums in the past and have experienced good vibes. Time to get back into the swing of things. Already snow on the ground here in Minnesnowda. GRRRR and BRRRRR
    In any case, just wondering if people out there use scents when they fish? If so, what type of scent (garlic, anise, shad, etc.)?
    Also, what are your favorite brands? Not putting in a plug for any one product or brand, just wondering what people use, if anything at all.

    suzuki
    Woodbury, Mn
    Posts: 18715
    #1472256

    I used one a few years back with some success. Enough that others fishing near me switched over to it. This was for walleyes. The problem was the mess it made. Oil based so it floated in the hole then ended up getting all over everything including saturating/staining the line and reel. It was more trouble that it was worth ice fishing in our opinion. I would rather catch fewer fish that crap all over my gear and ice house floor. BUT it can work. I heard about it from my brother that swore by it on Saginaw Bay one year. I don’t recall the brand. Pic of walleye on the label and smelled bad. )

    Jim Block
    Posts: 60
    #1472276

    Thank you for the reply. It can be messy! I carry a towel with me. It’s worth it to me to get a few extra bites, especially if it’s for a tournament. Ice time is almost here!

    Jim Block
    Posts: 60
    #1472278

    Thank you for the reply. Fish do seem to like it. I like garlic or anise personally. One makes me hungry for italian food, the other makes me hungry for licorice. Haha…the fish seem to like them both as well….and they aren’t as stinky as those craw or shad scents.

    nhamm
    Inactive
    Robbinsdale
    Posts: 7348
    #1472286

    If there are fish that react positively to scent, then there are some that should react negatively. So if you are willing to risk taking neutral fish turning positive, as well as turning some neutral to negative, then that’s your perogative.

    Seems the bigguns are smarter than the rest so I’ll take the chance of them turning positive rather than the latter. Doesn’t matter if they saw the bait 1x or 10x, if they don’t like what they smell they’ll never bite. Where as no scent they may eventually commit out of curiosity/annoyance.

    Jim Block
    Posts: 60
    #1472298

    If there are fish that react positively to scent, then there are some that should react negatively. So if you are willing to risk taking neutral fish turning positive, as well as turning some neutral to negative, then that’s your perogative.

    Seems the bigguns are smarter than the rest so I’ll take the chance of them turning positive rather than the latter. Doesn’t matter if they saw the bait 1x or 10x, if they don’t like what they smell they’ll never bite. Where as no scent they may eventually commit out of curiosity/annoyance.

    Interesting perspective. I’ve had more success turning fish on with scent, than without, but I see your point. I know of a testimonial where a guy won a tournament because he switched to using scent after fishing a spot for over 15 minutes, and wham! Nailed a 7lb smallie! Then that happened again on another spot about an hour later. There’s some really good and reputable research out there that shows the benefits of scent. But I really like your point too.

    Joel Ballweg
    Sauk City, Wisconsin
    Posts: 3295
    #1472458

    I agree with nhamm to a point. I’m a heavy scent guy and pretty much use it on everything, year round except for live bait. Been doing that for more than 5 years now and because of that, I have definitely noticed that there are times where my favorite scent has more of a negative effect than a positive one.

    Basically, I feel like I’m still learning how to maximize the use of scents on my lures. A big part of that, is learning when not to use a particular scent as much as it when I should be using them. After more than 5 years of use, I still feel like there is much to learn in that regard but have made some progress.

    As a whole, it would be extremely hard for me to believe that scents don’t increase my catch. We’ve simply caught way to many fish to believe otherwise. And many of those fish are big fish.

    This 29″ walleye, fell for a crankbait covered in my favorite scent last Tuesday night. She was not the only one. We’ve been out fishing at night twice this fall, and scored a bunch of good fish both nights.

    Personally, the question of whether scents work has already been answered. The thing I’m trying to figure out going forward is how, when and where.
    How to best use them and when not to use them at all.
    The where part is probably the most difficult. On my home waters, I know how, when and where. When I travel to different bodies of water, the use of scents becomes more problematic.

    Attachments:
    1. 11-04-14-Boog-29-inches_1.jpg

    Jim Block
    Posts: 60
    #1472604

    Hey Joel! When you figure out the ‘when’ part, let me know! Thanks for the post! Agree with you!

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.