been to joe tess and our table shared some carp because we had to. it was very fishy and very OK if you are used to eating panfish/walleye. but the reality was that it was HEAVY. and here is why. they score the carp every 1/8 of an inch to cut the bones but ALSO to get batter in between every 1/8 of an inch of the fish. i estimate it has 3x the batter on it than say a fillet of walleye of equal size. you can batter fry a shoe and it will be somewhat edible. i believe they also get the fish fresh and bleed them in tanks to get out as much blood as humanly possible.
i wouldn’t ever get the carp again.
my buddy and his dad kept a 5lb silver when they were walleye fishing and we ate it and it was delicious. to the point where if i catch small asian carp, i’d be inclined to keep it. they are filter feeders so their food source is the same as bluegill.