you can be disappointed by the fishing with any guide service, or happy with a drive to fish house out there. Speaking from experience out there and with Woodland/Perch Patrol. I have done it. It really comes down to the how the bite is. When the bite is off, its off.
One of my best ice trips was 1 day with the Perch Patrol and the next day with a fish house thru Woodland. We did great both days.
Went back a couple years later for a March per trip with Perch Patrol for 2 days. The bite was off everywhere, we spent most of the time walleye fishing to get a few. I dont blame them as we moved around, it was just an off bite