Same Buck?

What are your thoughts. The first picture is of the deer we called “Loppy” last year, and we never knew whether it was genetics or injury thatcaused his antlers to grow funny. The second pic is of a 15pt buck we have this year. I wonder if they are the same because loppy last year had a 5pt right side, and that is consistent to the 15pt this year. And the left side last year was messed up, but looking at the left side he had that one beam coming out of the back and im wondering if that could possibly be the sticker/droptine in this years 15pt?

I would say it’s a good chance, I’m looming at the pic from my I phone but to me looks like the end of the main beam has a similar hook to it.