Sounds like you had a good start to your hunting season. Deer sightings that is, Steve.
I noticed that you are shooting carbons. I’m not sure what kind though, which doesn’t really matter, because they are usually equiped with uni nocks. Meaning that they should be a snug fit, but still be able to turn the nock for proper arrow alignment. I would not recommend gluing them. Most carbons need an epoxy mixture. I would take your arrows to a local archery shop and tell them the problem. They should be able to find the right size uni nocks need for your arrows. You may have been given the wrong size nocks for the diameter size of your carbons.
Just curious also, Steve. Do you use a string loop to hook your release on or are you attaching your release straight to your bow string? Sometime when you attach your release to the bowstring below your arrow you get what’s called arrow pinch. Doesn’t always cause problems, but I believe in putting on a string loop to eliminate some release problems. A smoother release definately is achieved with a loop.
I have just made the switch over to Carbon Express arrows from my old reliable Easton Super Slams aluminums. I hated to, but after seeing how well the carbons perform it’s now not a problem. I hope this helps, Steve. If you have any more questions, I may be able to help. If not, I know a few people that can.