I refuse to hunt out of ANY tree stand without a harness. My number one priority is coming home safe!
I understand lots of your thoughts and perspectives on wearing them. I think of them like seat belts in a car. You may drive for 30 years and never need them, but the one time that you need it, you REALLY need it. Falling 17 feet from a tree stand will all but guarantee that you will hit the ground head first. Simple physics will pull the densest part of your body(your head) to the ground first. IF you survive, you will be seriously injured. No deer is worth that. Not to mention that after an accident like that, you’ll probably be done with your hunting career.
Now that I’m done preaching
, I wear an older shoulder type harness. I leave a strap in every set I have. I have a ring attached to the tree strap and a carabiner on my harness. Easy and quiet to clip in and be safe. I dipped both parts in plasti-dip coating to quiet them down.
I’m leaning towards buying the 30′ rope with the prussic knot attached to it. It allows a guy to stay strapped to the safety rope while climbing up and down. Its more likely that a guy will fall climbing than they will fall out of the stand. At $40 each, it will get expensive, but far cheaper and less painful than a trip to the ER ward.