In my personal leasing hunting land experiences, most land owners lease their land by the wooded acre. They are able to charge more per acre if it’s for the whole season (bow and firearm) versus only bow or only for firearm. Not sure what leases are going for in the area that you mentioned above. However, I would say $10 – $20 per acre is a good starting point if it holds some mature bucks. Over in coveted QDM areas such as Buffalo Co WI , they are charging $30 – $50 per acre.
And remember, most land owners are more concerned with how you will treat their land versus the money you will pay them. Make sure you state how you will not drive on their fields, that you will shut all gates, obey all hunting laws, will not cross any boundries or neighboring fences, and that you will leave the property exactly how you found it.
Tell them exactly how many hunters will be hunting on their property and how many deer you intend on harvesting. Tell them how you hunt (some land owners do not like deer drives) and if you intend on using tree stands tell them that you will not harm any trees and that you wll not use screw-in tree steps and you will use climbing sticks or ladder stands instead.
Tell them that you are willing to sign a lease agreement that will protect them financially from any hunting accidents should they unfortunately occur. And if you are willing, provide them a copy of your necessary insurance documents.
They are also concerned what the neighbors may think by leasing out their land to you. So I always say that I will not tell anyone where I hunt out and that I respect their privacy.
If you can bridge a personal reference with the land owner – that helps a lot. Can anyone vouch for you that the landowner may know? Bridge it if you can…
All of these little things help when trying to talk that landowner into a lease. Good luck!