Deer decoy?

  • bennyj
    sunrise mn
    Posts: 542
    #199765

    I have only used one once and I borrowed it. The deer didn’t come out that night so I am not sure if it would have worked.

    I have a foam target deer and one side of it is a cut away to see the vitals. So its not really a whole looking deer but I have this doe that seems to not might it. One night I was shooting at it and the doe didn’t seem to mind that either(out of season). My problem is that I am not so sure I want to use that thing in the woods.

    If you could choose anyone. What would you recommend for a decoy?

    Does anyone have any real experience with them good or bad?

    Thanks for the imput

    lick
    Posts: 6443
    #39180

    i have had both good and bad luck with the decoy sometimes they come running and sometimes they go the other way all depends on the deers mood never had a shooter come out to see it cant say yes or no sorry but they do work

    walleyebuster5
    Central MN
    Posts: 3916
    #39183

    I’ve often wondered this too.. But i’d be more likely to buy a doe than a buck. However,, I’m not sure of the manufacture but there is a doe decoy that I’ve seen in most outdoor stores and it looks like she just saw a spaceship fly down and take away her fawn!! I never understood the SUPER ALERT look they put on these things????

    robstenger
    Northern Twin Cities, MN
    Posts: 11374
    #39185

    As I have said many times before, “Decoying is a definite love/hate relationship.” There is a very minute window that decoying is effective IMO (10-20 days). The timing and location has to be just right. If those two things come together, decoying is unbelievably an effective tool and the funnest thing to witness. Use it not at the right time or location be ready for heart break.

    To fool a buck full of testosterone is not all that hard. The thing that will wreck it for you more times then not is the doe. I have had a doe over 100 yards away be upwind of my decoy and still blow clear the whole field numerous times. Or be uneasy enough where the shooter just off the field wanted to come out onto the field, but observed the does body language and turned the other direction.

    Food/Field edges can be great places to decoy, but be ready to have the field cleared by does also. Transitions (bottle necks) or staging areas are also great places as the does tend to just pass by and not observe pay attention the decoy as much.

    If you can add some realism to your set up by movement of the head or tail this increases your chances to fool the does and increases your chances on the mature buck when he arrives. Primos Scarface, Flambeau Masters, Carry Lite or the Buck Wing Bobb’n Head decoys are the most popular real life looking decoys. The Primos and Buck Wing are both wind activated motion decoys.

    I like to set up my buck decoys upwind 30 yards and quartering to me. I like for him to be in the open where he can be seen from some distance. The mature bucks will circle down wind of the decoy which puts them 30 yards or closer to me and they usually circle to the head which gives me a broad side shot of some kind. If I’m decoying I’m usually real aggressive with Horns and Grunts to attract attention. Also make sure you spray down the decoy with scent killing spray and wear latex gloves when handling. I usually put dominate buck urine on the ground or nearby branch to entice the mature ones to commit those last few crucial steps into the open for a shot.

    I do not decoy much with does. However have had some success with doe decoys during the peak of the Rut and have caught a few 2.5 and 3.5 year olds searching when the bigger ones have been locked down with some does.

    Like I said prepare yourself for some heart ache, but when it works, it sure is cool to see. Even if he is not a shooter that comes in. About my favorite thing in the world to see is a buck posture up and do that angled sideways walk into the decoy, no matter what the age of the buck is. There is nothing that gets the blood flowing more then seeing that.

    Good luck!

    mooneypm
    Ellsworth,WI
    Posts: 48
    #39190

    I have a couple decoys I use, the first is a full 3d decoy with removeable antlers , the second is a Renzo decoy, which is a 2d decoy with photo on both sides. I like them both but here are some pros and cons of both.

    3D Pros:
    *close to actual deer size
    *can be used as doe or buck
    *probably more life like
    3D cons
    *pain in the rear to haul
    *color faded after 2 seasons

    Renzo Pros
    *easy to carry along
    *picture very realistic
    *dont seem to fade
    Renzo cons
    *smaller than actual deer
    *placement is a little more tricky
    *I have had small bucks get spooked when they circle it and it dissapears

    Either way no matter what you use your most likely going to experience good and bad luck, but its fun trying new stuff isnt it!

    big_g
    Isle, MN
    Posts: 22548
    #39195

    I have a CarryLite that I have used a few times. It converts from doe to buck with a set of antlers. I like it because it all packs inside the body for transport. I have had does check it out, but never a buck… yet. I used it one muzzy season, and it brought a group of 4 does over, from about 1/4 mile away to check out.

    big G

    protourbaits
    stillwater, MN
    Posts: 2466
    #39196

    I too have had success w/ the Carrylite doe decoy. I have had does spook from the doe decoy. She/they don’t seem to like it at all Ive had a nice lookin 6 point come right up to the decoy after a few calls. Seems to work great in October

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.