We have been cutting our deer ourselves for many years.
It all depends on what you want to do with the deer.
What we do, is cut out the back loin, boneless and cut out the tenderloins on the inside, again boneless.
To do this, starting at the shoulder, make a long cut down the center of the back on each side of the spine. Basically, you are making one cut down the center of the spine, then when you hit the bone, “Y” it out to the ribs on each side, tight against the spine bone. Once you hit the ribs, stop with that cut. Then go at the deer with the knife at a 90 degree angle of the first cut (along the ribs about 4 inches away from the spine center), to cut out the back loin. Ta-Da!!! You have boneless steak!!! This cut, again should be from the shoulder to the rump. As you pull your knife down the back, you will “feel” where you should start and stop. It is easy.
Cut out the tenderloin on the inside.
As for roast;
Cut from the end of the leg, down the inside of the deer, along the leg bone. Work up to the “socket”. If you take your time, you can cut out the leg bone and remove it from the socket. This will leave you with a “massive” chunk of meat. The meat goes right up past the pelvic bone to the top of the rump. This is all roast meat. The closer you are to the top of the deer, the more tender the roast is (rump roast). Once you have this massive amount of meat cut out, cut out the roast you want. Typically, on a clean rump/leg, I will get 4 nice roast per leg that varies from 2 to 3 pounds each. The meat that I trim off my roast to make them “nice” I just use for trim for burger.
The front legs:
There really isn’t good roast here. So, with that said, I just cut it all into trim for burger or ground to do whatever you wish.
In cutting the front legs, pull the leg away from the deer and cut into the “armpit”. This will lead you into the shoulder blade. Cut around the shoulder blade and the front leg will literally fall off. Bone it out!!!
With that said, cut and trim the neck and the rest of the deer. Take your time, you really can’t screw it up, if you just go with the “seams” of the meat.
NOTE: Any meat that has fat (which is actually tallow), cut the fat off!!!! The fat gives you the “gamey or wild” taste. Add beef or pork fat to your ground trim to “juice it up”. DEER FAT GIVES DEER THE BAD TASTE!!!!!
With this said,
On any deer, you will get about
1: two, 2′ strips of boneless steak off the back.
2: two tenderloins from inside the deer (the tenderloin is basically two chunks of meat inside the deer, where the “small of the back” is. It is inbetween the ribs and the hips). These range about 12 to 15 inches
3: About 6 to 8 roast (3 to 4 from each leg)
4: About 25 to 35 lbs of trim for grinding.
On a 120lb doe, I will pull out about 50lbs of boneless meat.
As for what meat to throw away?
1: Any meat that darkens up because of dry blood (just shave off the dark areas.
2: Any blood clots.
3: Any meat that has any sign of being tainted by internal organs (gut shot), do not use!!!!!!!!! If the tenderloins got hit with guts, just throw them away!!!! It ain’t worth eating sour meat!!!!
Ask more questions!!! I know I didn’t cover it all!!!