What can this state/hunters do to better manage the herd.
It depends on what the goal is of the management. As a deer hunter I’d like to see more big mature bucks, overall more deer numbers and more people deer hunting. As a hunter I pass on small bucks, and would encourage anyone else that wants to shoot big bucks to do so. Same philosophy as what I do walleye fishing, let the 20″+ ones go, and you increase the odds of catching bigger 28″ picture/trophy fish. I don’t think we need Antler Point Restrictions as law, as some people don’t care and just want the meat and we want/need them to keep hunting. If you want meat, as I do, shoot a (as in one) doe or a fawn in a multi deer unit, and wait out Mr. Big. Voluntarily. Private landowners should work on their property to increase optimal deer habitat, which includes but is NOT limited to food plots (I think this is being done at pretty good scale already, but every little bit helps).
Controversial opinion(s) but I believe the DNR needs to end our current CWD management practice of obliterating deer herds anywhere there is a positive test. CWD has been in Colorado and Wyoming for decades, and Wisconsin for 20 years, if it destroyed deer herds or infected humans, we would likely know that by now. And secondly they need to manage the wolf population scientifically, not by activist opinion. I’m fine with wolves and think they have a place in the ecosystem, but the DNR is either inaccurate, incompetent or dishonest in the assessment of the number of wolves in the state and the territory they have expanded to. It is past time to reinstate a wolf hunt. Third, they need to simplify the regulations drastically on all fronts. I introduce a lot of people to both hunting and fishing and almost unanimously they say they would never take up the sport without someone to help them understand the rules. I believe it is a hindrance to growing the outdoors community, and there’s a lot of opportunity for easy common-sense simplification. And finally the DNR should prioritize accessing and utilizing the vast public lands we have here. Whether that be easements to land locked public, allowing bow hunting on all DNR managed public (there’s a lot of by cities that is closed to hunting and no reason bow hunting isn’t allowed imo), to developing it with hunting in mind by trail access or when and what’s done to the land after it is logged.
FWIW I think we have pretty good deer hunting in the state already, and think these ideas would just improve it in a fairly short order.