Crazy propane tank pricing!!

  • Chris Schoblocher
    Posts: 53
    #1738607

    Today I was at Menards looking at propane tanks and the pricing was crazy in my opinion. The prices where as follows.
    1# $3.37
    5# $39.99
    11# $56.97
    20# $23.99
    30# $48.97
    Now in my opinion you would think the 5# and 11# tanks would be cheaper than the 20#. I know 20# is the most common but dang why that much of a price jack up on the other tank sizes. Pretty sad I can get two 20# tanks for the cost of one 11#.

    Dusty Gesinger
    Minnetrista, Minnesota
    Posts: 2417
    #1738618

    It’s all about volume of manufacturing and sales.

    slipperybob
    Lil'Can, MN
    Posts: 1414
    #1738640

    A long time ago, 20# propane tanks used to be expensive too, then those exchange kiosks popped up all over the place and no one needs to buy a 20#. Unless it’s cheaper than the exchange rate initial purchase.

    Tuma
    Inactive
    Farmington, MN
    Posts: 1403
    #1738759

    The thing that I don’t like about the swap and exchange places is they only put 15lb in the tank.

    jake47
    WI
    Posts: 602
    #1738797

    The thing that I don’t like about the swap and exchange places is they only put 15lb in the tank.

    As opposed to how many lbs? I know our 500 gallon tank will only get filled to 85% to allow for thermal expansion w/o going boom!

    1hl&sinker
    On the St.Croix
    Posts: 2501
    #1738808

    As opposed to how many lbs?

    17 pounds. A few years back Blue rhino was caught selling 15 pounds for the same as 17 pounds without disclosing the difference in weight, class action lawsuits followed.
    I dont trust those exchange places, aside from not knowing what you get for weight you can still get stuck with a tank thats out dated. Happened to me twice, once at Menards and another time at a gas station.

    I normally refill but sometimes there are times an exchange fills a need when on the spot.

    Sam
    St.Francis
    Posts: 384
    #1738809

    <div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Tuma wrote:</div>
    The thing that I don’t like about the swap and exchange places is they only put 15lb in the tank.

    As opposed to how many lbs? I know our 500 gallon tank will only get filled to 85% to allow for thermal expansion w/o going boom!

    they can handle a full 20 pounds that will make the tank about 80 percent full in the winter I could fit closer to 25 pounds in there because of the lack of expansion

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.