I think we are all starting to figure out there is no perfect answer, andthere never will be. One of the best things all of can do is be open to change.. wheather its location or equipment.
At this point in time I could probably come up with a different rig perfect for each of my common spots I fish on the river, and I wouldnt be near comfortable with 1 combo to cover every spot, or 1 simple rig on the end of the line.
Flathead fishing isnt exactly finess fishing, but it does make a difference what you have on the end of your rod. What works one place doesnt always work 1 mile away.
Fishing shallow, deep, open areas, snags, culverts, water cannons, concrete debris, rubble, steel walls…. and thats only a few spots!
Theres no other fish to chase in MN and hook into a 40# fish that will run you 50′ into a culvert your standing on, then come out into the *water cannon*, then run you along the conrete wall hitting every jagged rock or concrete on the way.. if that doesnt shake the hook, they run back deep in the heavy current and make you lift them like a barn door… just to make a last ditch effort by scrapin the steel 3″ barge tie off cable before your partner can net the fish.