Info on MN State Record Flathead Catfish in 1970

  • steve-demars
    Stillwater, Minnesota
    Posts: 1906
    #1219617

    Back in February 2004 I did a post providing background information on the state record Flathead catfish. I thought this might be a good time to bring that post forward and give you all a target to aim at in the coming fishing season, here it is:

    I have been doing some research into the Minnesota state record Channel and Flathead catfish. The record Flathead is 70-pounds caught in 1970 in the St Croix River and the record Channel Cat is 38-pounds caught in 1975 in the Mississippi River. I was trying to narrow down as much of the fishing information as possible to improve my own chances of getting a record fish. I was trying to find as close as possible where it was caught,what kind of bait, etc, etc. I was able to visit the DNR Office where they keep the records and look at the Channel Cat and Flathead Cat record files. I was amazed to find that the files did not contain much specific information and that the verification procedures at that time was not a very rigid process. In the Flathead Catfish file the only verification of the fish was a newspaper article showing a picture of the fish and an interview with the fishermen involved. I couldn’t even tell what paper the article was from. The article was written by Hank Kehborn, the paper’s Outdoor Editor. Here is the information contained in the article:

    ” Ever wonder why the water levels of the St Croix River fluctuate to some fantastic degrees? Waterologists, if we may call persons who make a study of this matter by that name, will claim that rain, too much or too little, will keep shooting water levels up or shoot them down. That ain’t necessarily so.

    Five Iowa catfishing experts may have much to do with it by taking lunker cats out of the water near Marine-On-The-St Croix. The five are John Lee Robert and Clair Arnold of Garden City, Ralph Ligget of Des Moines and Howard Baker and Don Proctor of Humeston.

    During the past few days these catfish experts, who make annual trips to the river, have taken three beauties. The monsters weighed 70 pounds, 68 pounds and 24 pounds. “We took some smaller ones and a few carp but they don’t count,” Robert said. Is this luck or is it skill? Sid Cronell, owner of the Marine Boat and Canoe Service, said it’s skill. “They have been doing this for years,” he said. “There isn’t any luck connected with it. These guys know how to fish those big cats.”

    Robert, who landed the 70 pounder, said “we use deep sea fishing equipment with a 40-pound test line. We also use a big musky net.” And what’s the bait? Robert was a little hesitant about the bait being used but did admit that “we use just about everything”. Liggett, who landed the 68 pounder, also was reluctant to reveal the bait secret. The 24 pounder was taken by Proctor.

    Robert, who added that it takes a lot of time and patience to get the big cats, said that the river has some whoppers. “I had one break a 40-pound test line and last year we swamped the boat trying to land one.” They’re hoping to get that one back on the line.

    That was the article that garnered them the state record. Here is the picture: Does that look like a 70# flat? It sure is a nice fish anyway you look at it but I wonder if it’s 70# based on fish I have seen. I have some interesting information on the fish that was the record before this one took over – I will post that next. Here’s the pic:

    farmboy1
    Mantorville, MN
    Posts: 3668
    #431909

    I have to agree. Not being an expert on fish sizing, that fish goes nowhere near 70lbs. And is this weight a guess or is it actually a certified weight? This all seems a little far fetched for my thoughts.

    Is that a big fish, He;; Yes, Is it 70 lbs. problably not. Maybe the same guys who got a hold of the musky record need to look at this one

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.