Mr Special..
How come fighting a fish is the down side? Thats what I go fishing for… Its more fun to reel a fish in than it is to hold it after you landed it. Would that fish be all that exciting to hold if it didnt put up a battle on the way in?
I love to fight fish. I usually use just about the lightest tackle reasonable in the conditions given.
The *conditions given* is the key phrase. I know many of you guys fish most of the same areas I do. Mill Ruins is the main location in this case. Minimal snags, the barge channel(deeper water) can be a long cast depending on where your at… and there is a railing 5′ tall that we lean our rods against when we are fishing that end. Once you have a rod leaning at an angle against the rail.. a 6′ rod wont cut it unless you want your tip snapped immediately on a good bite, or a rod too heavy your not going to see the bite before the butt of the rod comes off the ground. A minimum rod length of 7′ is needed, 8’+ is ideal. The distance to cast to the barge channel, a longer rod is also what is needed.
Ok.. you know the rod length you want for those conditions.. now you need to decide what presentations you are using. The current is minimal most of the time(until the lock discharges) so you dont need a ton of weight, only enough to effectively cast your bait/load your rod properly to get a good cast. The heavier rod you choose, the heavier line your going to have, and the more weight it will take to cast properly considering rod load and line resistence. The lighter rod you use, the lighter the line, and lighter the weight that will be needed to achieve maximum casting distance.. and they also allow a more subtle bait presentation when needed, but you lose the ability to winch a fish in like the guys on the bassmaster circuit.
I guess its a choice between finess, casting, and bait presentation… or pure power.. your not going to get both out of one combo. In the end, get what best suits your preference. 95% of the time the subtle presentation will catch more fish early in the year.. come june, the fish really dont care anymore. At that time your going to be slinging bullheads most of the time anyhow.