I dont trust Kahl hooks to use in that location.. sometimes I do avoid getting the net when the fish are under 10 pounds.. I will simply hoist them up with the rod if its capable(one rod is).
I have never had much confidence in Kahl hooks.. I was a mono guy for years, and now have switched to power pro on my heavy cat gear.. the hooks that were damaged was with mono.. I cant see where it would stand up to the power pro when my drag is a little too tight.
I guess is what it comes down to.. I have never had good experience using kahl hooks.. The use of them turned more into a burden for me than a attribute…
Dont get me wrong, a Kahl hook is an excellent design. There is no hook out there that you will get better hook setting power because the point of the hook is pointing directly towards the eye of the hook, there is a very wide gap that should be helpful when a big flattie grabs the bait and the hook decides to go into the lower jaw.. they are an excellent design.. they just dont work for me and I have had my issues with them… Just like many people HATE circle hooks.
I can deal with strait shank hooks and circles.. Kahls drive me nuts.. I would probably use them more if the hook point was a bit longer.. that is one thing I really dont like, the short hook point.. I like the point to clear the bait without going up to a 15/0 hook (blown out of proportion, but you got idea).
I guess in the end we are best using what we have the most confidence in. I have been fishing cats for many years.. this doesnt mean I know everything.. but the equipment and tecniques I use with it I have down to an art form.. an entire world of trial and error that eventually resulted in very effective tecniques.
Brian saying the cross hooking bullies is very effective with the Octopus hooks. It works best if you hook towards the head, at an angle of at least 45 degrees, 60 degrees is even better if the bully is large enough. What is very nice about that hook, its constantly in position to hook into the fish and it will come strait out of the back on a hookset, not rip backwards out of the bait with the point laying parallel with the tail of the bait… this will increase your hookups with any type of hook with the probable exception of a circle.. it makes more sense to have the hook point turning up away from your bait that holding parallel to or worse yet, back into the bait… not to mention your bait will hold on the hook better because its going through twice as much meat as the standard.. strait across the dorsal, or tail hooking.
I dont critisize others for using different equipment, I simply watch and learn, or teach what I know when I go about things a different way. I wasnt telling anyone not to use kahl hooks.. I was simply stating that I have an extreme disliking for them.
Theres lots of guys out there fishing that all seem to do things just a little differently.. and we all have a little to learn, and teach to everyone. There are several different methods that are just as effective as an entirely different method being used for the same fish in almost the exact same circumstances.
Every year I fish for Flats.. these fish are teaching me more and more.. so are other anglers.. but sometimes we need to listen to the fish and forget what was working a week ago… because it might not be worth anything this week..
A good example is the clicker topic earlier this year.. These fish vary so much from location to location and their feeding habits. We had an extremely good spring this year and the fish were super aggressive. Out of about 60 fish, I think 2 of them didnt hammer it and scream the clicker immediately.. considering we were way above the water.. a clicker was the only way if you wanted to keep your fishing rod if you were 10′ away from your rod for more than 5 seconds… then one day someone hit a switch.. still tons of runs and couldnt hook anything.. then another switch got hit.. all the flatties were hitting like a perch on the end of the line.. if you didnt see it happen, you werent getting the fish.
Now the majority of our fish have been going the very small cut bait route and not bothering with any live bait.. at least live bait of any size.. I have been thinking about putting a couple fatheads on the hook like I do for early spring channels.. no joke.. they are that finicky over here right now.