Yup, what I’ve been doing with circles is the following:
I’m usually fishing with a bait runner reel, so I cast out, let it hit the bottom, reel up any slack, and trip the bait runner lever. Then, I’ll stick it the a rod holder and wait.
When a cat comes along, they’ll either take off with it or sit there and chomp on it. Either way, I pick up my rod, and if it is running, I’ll just reel in enough to flip the reel from bait-runner mode to the fighting drag and let the rod bend over before I start reeling.
If the fish is just sitting there, I’ll keep the tip up and reel in. You can usually feel what they’re doing, and I wait until I can feel it in their mouth pretty solidly, then I keep the tip high and just start reeling.
After I can feel the hook is in the fish, I like to give the rod a few good pumps just to make sure it’s in there solidly.
Well, that’s what I do. It worked pretty well for me last year. Some days were better than others, but I would assume it’s that way with any type of hook. The main thing to remember is to not pick up your rod and give it a good hook set because like you mentioned, you’ll just pull it right out of their mouth.