I’m not sure I’d say there’s any argument about flatheads in the winter, at least up here. It’s pretty well established that they’re down there doing absolutely nothing. Those that have “caught” them in cold water have done so with jigs and artificials which rarely produce well even when flats are slamming live bait in the spring/summer/fall. They basically drag hooks across the bottom and come across the occasional flathead. If they happen to be over an exceptional wintering hole, they hook lots of fish. But scuba divers and underwater cams show flats up here being completely immobile in the winter, building up silt on their backs. I catch them in the fall on live bluegills up until the water gets down to the upper 40s and can’t buy a fish after that. Folks like us need to lobby for a closed season throughout the region from November to March or April on flatheads. I’ve talked to a bass guy that knew where to catch flats and channels on pool 9 in the winter and he basically admitted it was a snagging excursion. He said it was like pulling rocks off the bottom. These fish are basically dead in the water after being pulled off their wintering holes. Any good catman wouldn’t be caught dead raping the resource in this way.
I knew it was over for me this year when I started pulling up walleyes in the 8-10lb range on my bluegills coming right out of my flathead spots (~35 feet down). You couldn’t find a walleye, even that size, anywhere near a spot full of active flatheads. It was fun, however, pulling in those wimpy walleyes, just to see how big they were. I kept a stringer of walleyes on one of my last excursion that had a 4lb average (most of those came on crankbaits I tossed while waiting for the flats to start up). I pulled one up to the boat that was about 10 pounds, but it had only gotten “hooked” by the bluegill’s spines and it slipped out of my hand on the first grab and got off (I occasionally pay for not bringing a net). My buddy Tom got a wallhanger though. Nice little bonus to soften the harsh realization that flatheading was over for another year.
I’m going to write a retrospective on 2004 soon and put it on my website – I’ll link to it here – it was a banner year in many ways.
Welcome, mile832 – Tim. Nice channels. Like Dirk said, watch out for BrianK – take it as a warning sign if you start to giggle and dwell on goofy things like gloves and whether people smile or not in their pictures that he’s rubbing off on you – avoid such a scenario at all costs! And resist the temptation to post pictures of yourself in the bathtub (not hard for most of us to resist, but there could be something in the water up there…)
Matt