Some guys insist upon using brand-specific oil, but I have been pleased with Pennzoil Marine XLF synthetic blend. If using a Yamaha oil doesn’t matter to you, Pennzoil is pretty affordable at Walmart.
“PENNZOIL MARINE® XLF SYNTHETIC BLEND 2-CYCLE OUTBOARD ENGINE OIL EXTENDED LIFE FORMULA
Pennzoil Marine® XLF Extended Life Formula TC-W3® Outboard 2-Cycle Synthetic Blend Oil was developed for engines that are “seasoned” or have been in service for a few years. The robust formulation makes Marine® XLF Extended Life Formula TC-W3® Outboard 2-Cycle Synthetic Blend Oil also very suitable for new high-displacement/horsepower carbureted or direct injection outboard motors.”