I am not sure if this is legal on the site or not but I am a real estate agent in WI and have been licensed for about 15 years.
Couple things that I would say in regards to all of this is:
1. working with one agent instead of several is a much better situation for you as a buyer. If you commit to an agent they will commit to you most times. As an agent it is frustrating when buyers are working through multiple agents. I have had situations where a buyer said “Hey if you find something let me know…” Only to contact them on a property that was just listed to find out… “oh yeah another agent we were talking to just sent us that one and we have a showing set up with them tomorrow?” I mean it is up to everyone to do what they want but for both sides it is nice to know that there is some trust involved.
2. Verify your agent. Most seasoned and well established agents will have a personal page with a short BIO that tells who they are and how long they have been an agent. Having a conversation with a potential agent prior to setting up showings sometimes is best. Agents do work harder when they know that they have “won” the job. Agents look at a buyer that has taken the time to look for an agent first as more serious and qualified and that leads to your agent working harder when they know they are not chasing the tail of a dog that isn’t going to hunt…
3. In this situation I would definitely look for an agent that is local to the area you want to be in. Big advantage is that the agent can preview homes for you so when things hit the market they can immediately get in there and check it out. I always tell my buyer that if I go look at something for them and I call them and tell them that they need to come look… that means ASAP. As everyone knows the market is tough now for buyers in a sense that there is a lot of competition. Another benefit of working with the local agent is that they would most likely know the listing agent personally and that can give you an advantage sometimes over working with an agent that does not know the agents in the area.
As a buyer now you just have to understand that the market is what it is. Is every buyer willing to pay $20,000 or something crazy over a list price? The answer to that is no. Is that what it takes now to get a property? Best answer to that is sometimes? Believe it or not even with higher listing prices you still sometimes find properties that undervalued even in this market. A buyer will know when they love something to the point that they will do what it takes to get the property and once again that is where having a good relationship and trust with your agent becomes important because you need to tell them that so they negotiate appropriately.
I wish I was in your area to help but I am in West Central WI but anyone looking please give me a shout through the site.
Good luck and embrace the hunt! Buying something in this market is more rewarding for buyers because it does take a little more effort and it is always worth it in the end!
X2 100%!