So I am sure it has been ask before, but cant find a search function on my phone. Buddy caught a 31 inch eye from the croix last night and is putting it on the wall. He would rather have quality than be real worried about price.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d60ca/d60ca5e6930a2b3ca34290cbadbcea95bd04e4f5" alt=""
Posts: 962
IDO » Forums » Fishing Forums » General Discussion Forum » Best metro fish taxidermist
So I am sure it has been ask before, but cant find a search function on my phone. Buddy caught a 31 inch eye from the croix last night and is putting it on the wall. He would rather have quality than be real worried about price.
http://www.nctaxidermy.com/763-757-7620_Rick_Simonson,_Owner.html
Rick is good! I have been using him for 19 years. not cheap but his air brushing is great! I will post some pics of my fish when I get home from work. He is located right by crooked lake in coon rapids
40 inch pike
29 im2ch rum river eye
21 inch rum river smallie
9.75 inch gills
I highly recommend Danny Beck’s taxidermy… It’s not metro but the quality is worth the drive.
Will
http://www.nctaxidermy.com/763-757-7620_Rick_Simonson,_Owner.html
Rick is good! I have been using him for 19 years. not cheap but his air brushing is great! I will post some pics of my fish when I get home from work. He is located right by crooked lake in coon rapids
Just did some work at his house last week. Wow. That place is beyond amazing.
click on “add file” and go to your pics and select one. some kind of text has to be on the post for it to post a picture, hense why I have periods at the top of each post.
<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>rubberduck wrote:</div>
http://www.nctaxidermy.com/763-757-7620_Rick_Simonson,_Owner.htmlJust did some work at his house last week. Wow. That place is beyond amazing.
Small world mike. Not to get off topic but did you see the wood carvings? He does wood arvings of world records and air brushes them….He has won several ribbons for his work!
He also does work for Lee and Tiffany Lakosky.
I have gotten 7 fish, 3 bears, 4 bucks, and 2 ducks, and two full body grey foxes and I have been a very satisfied customer!
Think I missed the wood carvings. There was far to much to take in and still try to get some work done.
He killed that fish?
It’s his right by all means but some of the replica’s are so good why kill a big fish like that? I know the fight can kill those fish sometimes, especially from deep water but I always like to see CPR with those monsters.
It is a monster from the St Croix – not sure I’ve seen one that big come out of there.
He killed that fish?
It’s his right by all means but some of the replica’s are so good why kill a big fish like that? I know the fight can kill those fish sometimes, especially from deep water but I always like to see CPR with those monsters.
It is a monster from the St Croix – not sure I’ve seen one that big come out of there.
35 fow good chance it would not have lived.
I would prefer a replica myself but considering the depth and water temp we figured he might as well keep it.
<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Matt Moen wrote:</div>
He killed that fish?It’s his right by all means but some of the replica’s are so good why kill a big fish like that? I know the fight can kill those fish sometimes, especially from deep water but I always like to see CPR with those monsters.
It is a monster from the St Croix – not sure I’ve seen one that big come out of there.
35 fow good chance it would not have lived
Fair enough…probably better to put it on the wall than hope it doesn’t go belly up floating downstream.
Beautiful fish for sure.
<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Justin riegel wrote:</div>
<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Matt Moen wrote:</div>
He killed that fish?It’s his right by all means but some of the replica’s are so good why kill a big fish like that? I know the fight can kill those fish sometimes, especially from deep water but I always like to see CPR with those monsters.
It is a monster from the St Croix – not sure I’ve seen one that big come out of there.
35 fow good chance it would not have lived
Fair enough…probably better to put it on the wall than hope it doesn’t go belly up floating downstream.
Beautiful fish for sure.
Quite the dilemma, probably start a thread on that alone. No right or wrong answer.
I don’t know what I would do if I ever was holding a 30+ eye.
<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Matt Moen wrote:</div>
<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Justin riegel wrote:</div>
<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Matt Moen wrote:</div>
He killed that fish?It’s his right by all means but some of the replica’s are so good why kill a big fish like that? I know the fight can kill those fish sometimes, especially from deep water but I always like to see CPR with those monsters.
It is a monster from the St Croix – not sure I’ve seen one that big come out of there.
35 fow good chance it would not have lived
Fair enough…probably better to put it on the wall than hope it doesn’t go belly up floating downstream.
Beautiful fish for sure.
Quite the dilemma, probably start a thread on that alone. No right or wrong answer.
I don’t know what I would do if I ever was holding a 30+ eye.
Probably set the beer down and use both hands…..
He killed that fish?
It’s his right by all means but some of the replica’s are so good why kill a big fish like that? I know the fight can kill those fish sometimes, especially from deep water but I always like to see CPR with those monsters.
It is a monster from the St Croix – not sure I’ve seen one that big come out of there.
OMG that didnt take long! That fish looks real old but a fish of a lifetime for sure. why can’t we just congratulate these proud sportsman instead of bashing them if they want to have a skin mount instead of a replica? I got a guy that makes skin mounts that look nothing like a replica…….not even close! Oh and by the way, I rarely keep fish and it would take a special one but it would be a skin mount…….suit yourself on the replicas. Congrats on the fish……..that is a moment your buddy will never forget!
Congratulations on the trophy ! She’s a beauty. I too would mount it especially after you let it go when it was 28 1/2 ” long. Sorry for the people who may criticize you for keeping it
OMG that didnt take long! That fish looks real old but a fish of a lifetime for sure. why can’t we just congratulate these proud sportsman instead of bashing them if they want to have a skin mount instead of a replica? I got a guy that makes skin mounts that look nothing like a replica…….not even close! Oh and by the way, I rarely keep fish and it would take a special one but it would be a skin mount…….suit yourself on the replicas. Congrats on the fish……..that is a moment your buddy will never forget!
[/quote]
Where did I bash the guy – read the whole thread or the whole post and I think you’ll see I made it clear it’s his right and I congratulated him on the fish. I have a handful of trophy fish that are made into replica’s – that’s my prerogative. I prefer to CPR but, like I stated, if the fish was stressed I would probably do the same thing. It’s your prerogative and the ops buddies to do a skin mount…more power to ya.
Congrats! The battle scars are what makes these big fish so unique.
Scott Miller in Prescott is top notch, IMO. He’s done birds for me and many of my friends. I would not hesitate bringing a fish in to him, the work he has on his walls are amazing.
I had a 30.25″ on LOTW about 5 years ago. I had nothing to preserve the fish for a skin mount, otherwise I would have taken her home. I ended up taking tons of pictures in hopes of doing a replica sometime down the road…who knows if it will happen.
NICE fish!!! replicas are exactly that I had 1 done on a 30 inch river eye 12lb 6 ounce fish no character not exact measurements as 30″ long and 18″ girth was not available she had scars and battle wounds that could not be copied! so eagle or turtle food or a once in a lifetime catch on the wall! people complain about a once in a lifetime fish but what about the guys who take full fish limits home every time
He killed that fish?
sounds like a complaint……
Nope. You’re making something out of nothing. Just stop.
Fantastic fish for justin’s friend.
P2F, you’d have to brain dead to think he wasn’t taking a shot…
First off, it was a question that the op answered.
For those of you that are uncertain, the question mark denotes a question.
A complaint would most likely be denoted by all caps or an exclamation point at the end.
This is a complaint and comment….stop being so sensitive! Read the rest of my comments and I think you’ll see I agreed with ops buddy once he said it came out of 35 fow and probably wouldn’t have survived.
survived or not he caught it he has a fishing license so his choice! why would we need all the negativity? say not shoot a big buck cuz you killed that bloodline? maybe just hunt with a camera? leave the guy alone do you take fish home to eat them? you might have killed a future trophy fish
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.