Color-another oxymoron

  • riverfan
    MN
    Posts: 1531
    #1214216

    Guys,

    Wanted to start another post to bring up some other thing to think about. I don’t have the magazine in front of me but in a recent In-Fisherman in the short technical articles there was a piece that estimated what size of an object a fish can see. Experts in eye physiology say that a fish can only see something about the size of a dime on edge. If that true, can a fish see a few red flakes in a black tube or a red hook? Doesn’t sound like it but the next question is would the flake or hook create some kind of blurred pattern? Most of the discussion about color here has been one-dimensional. Here is another one to ponder. How does a color appear when a fish is looking up from below into the glare of the sun, verses looking down at the bottom or from the side? I have to say I’m a color non-believer but I’m very much into contrast. Which colors produce contrast that set them selves apart? Which colors contrast with their environment? It changes with light conditions, it changes with viewing angles, and it’s constantly changing. All I can say is in my experience there are some combinations that work 90% of the time in certain conditions. I don’t know why but they catch fish. I suspect everyone is sick of hearing me run-on about pseudo science and anthropomophic thinking (trying to apply our knowledge into another creature’s world) but the color discussion is a classic example of it. It’s fun to speculate but we simply don’t have the answers. I subscribe to observe what’s going on around you and compare it to past experience school. Good old time on the water.

    mossboss
    La Crescent, MN
    Posts: 2792
    #271773

    Without a doubt, I think it is the blurred vision of color the fish sees, not the actual individual flakes. Especially in the lighter natural colors. Watch a watermelon worm in the water moving, blur of light green, watermelon red flake is a blur of red and green, watermelon candy a blur of different greens. Being one of poor natural wision (and thick contacts) I imagine the fish kind of see what I see when I take off the glasses and move a bait 2 feet in front of my eyes. The “flake” baits add more of a flash look as well.

    On the looking up looking down thing, I always take that into account. Baitfish are white on the bottom and green, blue, or dark on the top. People give me wierd looks as I hold plastics up to the light to look through them and then put them against green walls to get another view!!

    haywood04
    Winona, Minnesota
    Posts: 1073
    #271786

    Quote:


    People give me wierd looks


    MossBoss, I bet they do!

    See ya on the water tonight, we will experiment with your wision differences.

Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.