Hey Jake………I’ve played the “clearance game” since 1998 and fall can be good but the REALLY good deals come pouring in around Feb/Mar. Reason is that ice fishing is wrapping up and they need to get that stuff gone and they’re also beginning to stock up for the new season and all the discontinued stuff gets slashed to make room. There’s other times too where there’s just too much of an item and they want to reduce the “on hand” stock.
I know dept. stores can vary in their prices (Stillwater and Hudson WalMarts often have different prices) but in my area, most WalMart’s are actually more expensive for buying line or high demand lures like Rapalas. Hudson Fleet Farm is cheaper than Hudson WalMart and Galyan’s is surprisingly, often, cheaper than either one for the retail price of these given items. However, they usually don’t have much in the way of clearance sales so the trip isn’t always real beneficial. Gander can have some EXCELLENT closeouts so don’t ignore them! They also tend to have a better selection than regular dept. stores so you’ll get lures you can’t get anywhere else. And yes……………they may be “cheap, junky lures” but Rivereyes and I both laughed ourselves sick one day because we reduced ourselves to using “things we’ve never used before………..ever” and couldn’t keep the fish off of them! It would’ve never happened had I not gone into a Fleet Farm, Gander Mountain, or Galyans and got lures for 30%-80% off that WalMart has never carried.
Like I said, it varies from area to area but this is what my experience is here.
Another place to look for good price per lure is in the tackle box catagory of Ebay. I’ve seen some incredible deals happen that way and a good way to discover that “secret lure” that somebody else used a lot and is no longer available anywhere. I got a quintet of rattle cranks that consistantly pull fish when used that I obtained that way. Paid about 35 cents a piece when averaged out and four years later, I STILL have no idea what they are or who made them! All I know is the action is good, true, and they’ve all produced fish!