I have caught a few fish on them, but nothing to write home about. In fact, two weeks ago I fished a tournament with a B.A.S.S. pro whos main sponsor was Rad Lures (Chatterbait) and he threw a horny toad all day. Seriously!
I normally throw them wherever I throw a spinnerbait. Most people will say you can throw them where you throw a swim jig… but that’s not true for me. I just can’t get it to come though any vegetation. I haven’t tried their new “weedless” model, but I have a hard time believing anything with a blade on the front of it is going to pull through grass, cabbage, etc… very good.