I’ve used both types and neither is perfect. I used the safety pin type, Bassmaster brand first. First I don’t like poking the hole in the jaw but actually had the fish break the chain on it about 4 or 5 times in a year.
Then I tried the clip on type from Bag-Em and I wasn’t very happy at first. They kept faling off when I clipped them on the bottom of the jaw. Then I found out I needed to clip them on top just like the picture on the package. Since doing that I’ve been very happy with them.
I do have one come off about every other trip but it isn’t a problem because with the other 4 still on it is easy to tell the other one apart. You can’t pull the fish out by these clip on types but use it to guide your hand and then grapb their mouth to pull them out.
I should probably say, once I warmed up to the clip on I became a rep for Bag-Em products. Some might think this taints my opinion but I promise you if I don’t use their stuff I wouldn’t sell it.
Either way I hope you give them a try. If you can’t find them locally let me know. I do have a few sets I might part with but with shipping you’d save money trying to get them locally.
Here is their website. Bag-Em