Was in the same boat last summer. Advice people gave me appears to be right on as far as don’t buy more power than you REALLY need because it just makes for a bigger, heavier, and thirstier ATV. I can understand where guys out elk hunting above 9000 feet need more power because altitude gobbles up HP, but here in MN…
Ended up with a Sportsman 500 bought used and it’s more than enough power. I pull a 400 pound 4 foot food plot disc with no problem whatsoever, so for what you mention, IMO you don’t need to go any bigger.
The used market kind of depends on where you live. In the cities, I found a lot of machines that guys used once or twice a year for hunting camp or whatever and then they sat around in the garage or shed for the other 360 days a year. Like somebody pointed out with the 2009 that I bought, the total mileage on the machine was = less than one trip to the mailbox per day. So relative to the cost of new, used was a good deal to me anyway.
Grouse