In my opinion, if you hunt and shoot 20-25 yards or under the Whisker Biscuit would work just fine for you. Personally, I would still go drop away, but to each their own. If you tend to shoot longer distances, this is where the biscuits really hurt arrow performance/flight and I would then definitely go to a drop away style.
The drop away rests now have products where they grab your arrow while the arrow is sitting on your rest before you draw so it don’t fall off.
After my WI Turkey Season this week, I’m heading in and getting a Schaffers Drop Away rest put on.
CLICK HERE to view the rest. Then select what bow you have along the bottom for more detail on that rest. This rest by Schaffer is rock solid, quiet, and a proven arrow rest and is what I will be shooting here soon.