I would like to try these but I just stocked up on the Rapala version this year and I have a box full of Chubby Darters and Zippers from last season that I rarely use.
The Rippin’ Raps work really well for me, especially at drawing fish in for a look. Getting them to commit to a strike takes a bit of finessing but they really do work. I imagine the HD Ice lures work much the same. The Darters and Zippers haven’t worked for me. I give up on those. I guess when you have aggressive feeders they might work but I wouldn’t know.