You might lose top end going to a 17. I don’t have the same motor as you, but when I dinged up my original prop, they gave me a different one to use until my replacement came in. I believe it was a 15×21 (Suzuki 150) and I was getting 50mph on GPS. When my replacement prop came in, same as the original one I dropped down to about 47. This prop is a 19.
42 certainly is slow for the boat and that motor. I have a 150 and I get 45 with a full tank and 4 guys with gear.
Are you trimming the motor up when WOT? Keep trimming it up until the boat catwalks and then lower it a bit so you don’t cavitate or porpoise.
If you are already doing that, raising the motor might in the cards. mine is in the second hole from top.