Justin…Not sure which guide or lodge you used in Kenai/Soldotna, but the places I’ve been to my trip was based on hours, not limits. I can book either a 6 hour or 10 hour trip. FYI, you can catch and release after retaining a limit of reds, and same with pinks. But, once you retain a king, or your August limit of two silvers, you have to quit for the day. My guides have allowed me to release kings (when it’s open), and silvers if I choose to. When booking next time, ask your lodge owner or guide how they handle their day. With nearly 300 guides on the Kenai river, there will be one that will fish the way you want to fish.
We fished with Jimmy Jack, and actually got to go out with Jimmy himself, it was great!
We were up in August fishing for silvers at the time, and we caught tons of pinks incidentally. But we weren’t really given the option of throwing a silver back to try and get a bigger one, once you boated it you kept it.
Which was fine! But just a different experience than say a Canada trip or something.
Same goes for our halibut fishing, but I would NOT recommend going with our charter, Puffin charters. I guess I can tell the story here and I’ll try to be brief.
We showed up to the charter boat with the other ~10 people, and unsurprisingly it was chilly and rainy nearly all day. Some of the other guests included a couple from Hawaii who were only wearing jeans, flip flops, and a sweatshirt, and quite a few older couples.
We went through the setup once out there, drop your line 500 ft down to the bottom, watch your rod tip, if you get a bite start reeling hard until you know you have a fish. Limit is 2 halibut per person with 1 being over 30″ or something(forget the exact number).
45 minutes in, half the guests are in the cabin of the boat because they are too cold to fish. My wife and I and one other couple are the only ones braving the elements. I catch a halibut that’s over the 30″ threshold, but not by a lot. They tag it with one of our colored zip ties and then tell me that from now on, if I get a bite I need to tell the crew so someone else can come and reel the fish in. “Whoever sets the hook keeps the fish, that’s the regulation. And if you catch another big one, we’ll have to throw it back. We want everyone on the boat to get a big one first before you catch anymore.”
So basically, ‘sit out here, watch your line, and if you get a bite we’ll go grab someone from the warm cabin to set the hook’. This happens a couple of times before I say F it, I’m not going to do that anymore.
Then my wife catches a halibut, gets it next to the boat and the crew gets excited, “Nice! that one’s under 30!”. They gaff it, get it on board, and it measures 30.25″. “welp, that’s your over 30.” I asked why they didn’t net it if it was close, because we would have thrown it back and tried for a bigger one and they just kind of ignored me.
So we were both ‘done fishing’ until the rest of the boat got their over 30″ fish, even though half the boat was just sitting in the cabin not fishing.
Then my wife sets the hook on a nice fish and is fighting it when the staff basically pull her off the rod and tell her she needs to let the person next to her reel it in. So they do, and it’s a big cod. My wife loves cod. They bring it on board, congratulate the other guy and put one of his zip ties on the fish.
I say, “hold on, that’s our fish.”
Crew member: “No it’s one, this gentlemen reeled it in so it’s his fish.”
Me: “But you told us whoever sets the hook owns the fish, that’s the regulation.”
Crew member: “He set the hook.”
Me: “Uhhh, he absolutely did not.”
Crew: “he’s the one holding the rod.”
Me: “Well why don’t we ask him. Sir, did you set the hook on this fish?”
Other guy: “uhhh, I reeled it in”
Me: “But who started reeling it in?”
Other guy: …. *eventually points to my wife*
Crew: *begrudgingly removes their zip tie and puts on of ours on it*.
I doubt that’s how all charters run out there, but I also doubt that this one is alone in how they operate. if you’re on a charter with a big group, their number one goal is to probably try and make sure everyone goes home with something. That’s an honorable goal, but it just didn’t feel like we got our money’s worth, especially when we were some of the only ones putting in any effort.